On the menu
Saturday, Nov 19, 2005
I want to know if anyone really eats the cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving. Really, do people eat that stuff with a regular chicken dinner? It’s a marketing ploy, I tell you. Do you put a dab on your plate just to be polite? Does anyone really like it? Should I rebel and leave it off the menu? And, why (!) do I wrap up the leftovers, only so it can be found as another chemical compound four weeks later and pitched?
For Thanksgiving this year, our menu will look like this:
–Turkey (I’m using this brine, but I always cook it upside down for the moistest breast meat.)
–Garlic Mashed Potatoes, leave the skins on
–Buttered Corn
–Green Beans with almonds
–Homemade Macaroni and Cheese, using extra sharp cheddar is the trick
–Stuffing and Gravy from the pan drippings
–Buttered Rolls
–Cream Cheese Pumpkin Pie
–Bubbly grape juice for all
–Pumpkin Cream Cheese Muffins for breakfast, just because I like cream cheese
and
–Cranberry sauce…I’m a wimp.
44 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
During the thanksgiving meal, I eat the cranberry sauce to be polite. I don’t like how it goes with the other flavors, particularly the potatoes and string bean cassorole (a family tradition). I do, however, enjoy spreading a little cranberry sauce on the leftover turkey meat when eating it as a sandwich. The sandwich, minimally, includes cheddar (sharp preferred) and lettuce.
Comment by Dave (November 19, 2005 @ 10:56 am )
I love cranberry sauce. I especially love it homemade, which is very easy to do.
Cranberry Sauce
Comment by Kim (Coffee and a Muffin) (November 19, 2005 @ 12:12 pm )
I love cranberry sauce, thankyouverymuch. =8^o
One of the best parts of Thanksgiving is great whacking big bunches of cranberry sauce snuggled alongside the turkey and dressing!
Y’all ain’t right. ;^)
Comment by Anne (November 19, 2005 @ 12:45 pm )
Love the cranberry sauce. Each bite must have a smidgen of cranberry sauce, a bite of turkey, and a bit of gravy and dressing. The contrasting tastes all mixed together are delicious. Try it. That funny looking guy thought he wouldn’t like green eggs and ham either.
Comment by Sherry (November 19, 2005 @ 12:45 pm )
I like the cranberry sauce on my turkey. But I didn’t always like it, I guess after so many years of taking it to be polite I’ve developed a taste for it
Comment by Jasmine (November 19, 2005 @ 2:34 pm )
My dad and my son both *adore* cranberry sauce — but it has to be real sauce, made from real actual fresh cranberries, and not canned. I don’t like it, though, even when it’s done right.
My turkey trick: Put stuffing between the skin and the breast as well as in the cavity, and use a roaster oven or at the very least a roasting bag.
Comment by Rachel (November 19, 2005 @ 3:08 pm )
I like the cranberry sauce. We need it more for the leftovers than the actual meal. My hubby makes this weird turkey sandwich - turkey, stuffing, cranberries and…mayo with the leftovers. Sometimes I don’t serve it during the meal but always have plenty on hand for the sandwich.
Comment by Sal (November 19, 2005 @ 5:41 pm )
I don’t get the cranberry thing. To me, it would be like putting grape jelly all over a steak. Keep the gelatinous sweetened goo away from my meat!
Otherwise, it sounds yummy, Amy.
Comment by mopsy (November 19, 2005 @ 7:39 pm )
Cranberry sauce is GREAT STUFF! I would eat it with grilled chicken if it was served…
Comment by Tim (November 19, 2005 @ 7:56 pm )
Because the I-hate-cranberry-sauce group is being outnumbered here in the comments, add me to the I-won’t-touch-the-stuff list. The only people I know who eats it is my best friend. I just don’t get it!
Now, dried cranberries is a whole ‘nother story… love those!
Comment by Anita (November 19, 2005 @ 8:51 pm )
I lovelovelove cranberry sauce. But only the jellied stuff, and only if it’s thoroughly chilled.
I used to eat it as an after school snack when i was a teen.
Comment by Maggie (November 19, 2005 @ 9:15 pm )
I’m in the “only use it to decorate the table” group, but I tried a new recipe last year and thought I would share. I actually like this recipe. I got it from http://www.flylady.net. Basically you make it like normal (with recipe on the back of the bag of fresh cranberries) EXCEPT replace 1/2 of the water with orange juice. It does WONDERS!
Comment by Nancy (November 19, 2005 @ 9:50 pm )
Cranberry sauce! I tell you–poultry is not complete, in my humble opinion, without the accompaniment of a goodly portion of cranberry sauce. Canned or homemade, I don’t care–I am proletarian at heart. Thanksgiving would not be as good, nor would even a thigh of chicken be as delightful, if I could not have some cranberry sauce on the side.
Apple sauce is great to have with beef or pork, but not with poultry. Gotta have the sauce!
Yum!
Comment by Ed (November 19, 2005 @ 10:02 pm )
LOVE the cranberry sauce with a dab of stuffing and turkey all in one bite–YUMMY! ;o)
Try the delicious strawberry jello recipe which has fresh cranberries, sugar, mandarin oranges, crushed pineapple and apple chunks. Delicious!
Off to check your recipes….cream cheese……mmmmm!!!!
Happy Thanksgiving preparations.
Comment by Julie (November 19, 2005 @ 10:26 pm )
MMm…I so love cranberry sauce, especially homemade. SOOOOO YUMMY!!!
Comment by Sheri (November 19, 2005 @ 11:04 pm )
I have to make my kids eat their turkey first before I’ll allow them the cranberry sauce…I mean, really, the stuff is glorified Jello. Anyone here ever see the Thanksgiving episode of Frasier where Marty gets on Daphne for making lumpy cranberry sauce from scratch (along w/ the rest of the dinner), saying, “It’s supposed to keep the shape of the can! Is it that you can’t learn or won’t learn?”
Comment by Cathy in NOLA (November 19, 2005 @ 11:05 pm )
I was a Sam’s club today and almost bought the 8-pack of cranberry sauce! It is so yummy.
I’m with the crowd that has to have cranberry, turkey, gravy, and stuffing in every single bite. And it has to be on a sandwich with turkey, gravy and butter. I like to have it with baked chicken any time of year too. And in that above-mentioned jello recipe. And on ham or pork roast mixed with orange juice, brown sugar, cloves, and cinnamon. I also drink cranberry juice mixed with sprite and pretend it’s a wine spritzer. If any sauce is leftover, it gets thrown into a coffee cake along with shredded apples and more cinnamon. mmmmm
Why would you take food just to be polite? Do you then eat it? If you don’t, then it just gets thrown away, and that seems less polite than not taking any. Why would you use up valuable space on the crowded thanksgiving dinner plate for something that doesn’t make your mouth happy? Somebody please ’splain this to me.
Comment by Jo in Orlando (November 19, 2005 @ 11:40 pm )
I don’t care for cranberry sauce, it would be good if it just didn’t have that bite to it. I have a recipe for a great frozen cranberry dish. I love it, it’s like a dessert. I posted on my site last week (www.sarahellsworth.typepad.com).
Comment by Sarah (November 20, 2005 @ 12:52 am )
Our family is very much into cranberry sauce — to the point that I usually make and serve two to three versions of it. This year I’m planning on making:
1. The old standby: cranberry sauce with apples and cinnamon, cooked in cider and white wine instead of water.
2. The new standby: cranberry sauce with mandarins and ginger.
3. The odd quirky one: cranberry “salsa” with jalapena peppers.
I also make two to three different stuffings/dressings as well. We really get into Thanksgiving!
Cranberry sauce is not just reserved for that one meal. We’ve also served it with chicken, cornish game hens, and even my husband’s special meat loaf.
Comment by Rebecca (November 20, 2005 @ 12:28 pm )
I love cranberry sauce! I usually have some cranberry sauce with every bite of turkey and/or stuffing, and usually more than a “smidge.” I probably eat over half a can of the stuff all by myself. (And only the whole-berry stuff will do; none of this jellied cranberry sauce for me, thank you! However, I have to buy the jellied cranberry sauce, because my husband likes it.)
Newt
Comment by Newt Sherwin (November 20, 2005 @ 5:24 pm )
Oh dear me. No mixing food people! And no I don’t eat the cranberry sauce. I love to make the fresh stuff though
Those pretty little cranberries going “pop, pop, pop”. There is something very special about the canned sauce, plopped out onto a dish, dented with the can lines and cut in to slices. But for goodness sakes, don’t eat it.
Comment by Janet (November 20, 2005 @ 7:38 pm )
It’s true, once you’ve made the sauce from scratch and hear the pop, pop, pop of the cranberries in the pan–you’ll never be quite satisfied with the canned again. If there’s only canned, I’ll have a bit but if it’s the real thing–YUM! [watch out for popping cranberries--they can fly far and leave their mark!]
Amy, did you plan on creating all this stir–tsk,tsk…(wink, wink) ;o)
Comment by Julie (November 20, 2005 @ 10:26 pm )
I SOOOO love cranberry sauce. I especially like a turkey sandwhich with a thin slice of sharp cheddar, thin slices of tart apples and cranberry sauce. Sounds weird, but it is delicious!
And while I am here… TAG, You’re it. For instructions on how to play check out my latest blog entry (entitled “TAG”, of course!)
http://www.quietcajun.blogspot.com
Comment by Christina (November 20, 2005 @ 10:49 pm )
Amy, perhaps you didn’t mean to cause such a scandal with your anti-cranberry-sauce post, but I was so troubled all day that I had to respond on my blog, in a post I titled “Thanksgiving Heresy”, at http://blogmuse.blogspot.com/2005/11/thanksgiving-heresy.html
Maybe I’ll have to make a fourth cranberry sauce, just to make up for all of those who speak against the sacred American tradition.
Or maybe I’m just taking all this a bit too seriously? Nah…
Comment by Rebecca (November 20, 2005 @ 11:43 pm )
We eat it, and we actually like it. Fruitcake on the other hand, is another story. I believe if memory serves, that was one of the plagues on Egypt.
Comment by Carla (November 21, 2005 @ 10:02 am )
My mother was the only one in our family who cared for cranberry sauce. I don’t care for jams / jellies / preserves generally, so I figured that was the reason I didn’t like it.
And, um, Amy . . . Canadian Thanksgiving was loooooong ago–last month–so would you mind awfully if I came for dinner? I’ve been dieting, and your menu is making me drooooooooooooooooooooooooooool . . . .
Comment by Mrs. P. (November 21, 2005 @ 11:02 am )
I’ve never known anybody to actually eat the cranberry sauce and enjoy it. However, I’ve started making a fresh cranberry relish instead. All you do is put a bag of fresh cranberries, a cut-up orange with the skin still on, and a handful of walnuts through the food processor, mix with a cup of sugar, cover and let sit in the fridge for 24 hours. It’s SOOO yummy!
Comment by Diane (November 21, 2005 @ 1:54 pm )
I do declare that this is out of control.
There’s always room for one more, Mrs. P. I need someone to eat that cranberry stuff.
Comment by Amy (November 21, 2005 @ 2:13 pm )
Uh count me in for loving cranberry sauce too. I suppose you aren’t much for pickles either?
Comment by Lyn (November 21, 2005 @ 9:34 pm )
I know people who like it, but I don’t eat it. I find the taste is too strong and overpowers everything else.
Comment by Ron (November 21, 2005 @ 9:36 pm )
I never used to like cranberry, but now i love it.
Btw…….what is up with the brine thing? I have never heard of it before this year. Where have i been, but it is all over the food network. Emeril was doing it, too.
Your menu sounds wonderful, hope it’s great!
Comment by peri (November 21, 2005 @ 11:26 pm )
i like cranberry sauce but not the jelled kind in a can, the kind with berries. i’ve made the homemade cranberry sauce and liked it but didn’t think it tasted THAT much better to be worth the extra work. i can go either way with it. i highly recommend it with leftover turkey sandwiches. i read that in a magazine a few yrs. ago and really liked it. i love things tart over sweet. i can pass up a dessert b/f i can pass up many of the main meal ingredients…especially if they are tart! obviously, cranberry sauce really fills that bill. thanks for more ideas for cranberries.:) martha
Comment by martha (November 22, 2005 @ 1:15 am )
I have used a brine for the past 7 years. I always cook the turkey upsidedown too. I must say, even the white meat is VERY moist. Now the “cranberry” thing - I make sure I have a can of the jellied on hand for my dad. Has anyone been to the “cranberry bogs” in New Jersey”? It is awsome to see the cranberries harvested. Still don’t care for them though.
Comment by Tracey (November 22, 2005 @ 8:26 am )
My mother-in-law hates cranberry sauce, but always has a little on Thanksgiving. Not to be poliet, that’s just the only time she’ll eat it. And my brother-in-law is the asst. manager at a cranberry bog here in northern WI. He loves those little buggers! I like cranberry sauce, but not cranberry juice. My mom always makes a sauce of cranberrys, walmuts, celery, sugar (lots!), and an orange. She puts it all in a food processor and viola!, much better then the canned stuff. Interestingly enough, my mother-in-law makes the same kind, only sets it in a cherry jello. Both or wonderful! And I love eating the stuff just by itself (the “salad” that we make anyway, not so much the canned stuff)!
Happy Turkey Day everyone!
Jennifer
Comment by Jennifer D (November 22, 2005 @ 10:45 am )
[...] 6. In lieu of content, insult people everywhere by saying something noncommittal, like, “I can’t believe people actually eat cranberry sauce. Only heretics eat [...]
Pingback by Amy’s Humble Musings » Top 10 Ways to Get Hits (November 22, 2005 @ 4:15 pm )
I love, love, love canned jellied cranberry sauce. I eat regularly, even for dessert.
Comment by Nicole (November 23, 2005 @ 1:24 am )
My mom eats it. She’ll eat the entire can…although she is the only person I know that actually eats it.
Comment by Bethany (November 23, 2005 @ 8:45 am )
I love cranberry sauce too. Honestly, Thanksgiving without it is just wrong:)
Happy Thanksgiving!
Comment by Ron (November 23, 2005 @ 12:53 pm )
[...] . You are probably elbow deep in turkey-carving euphoria, happily dishing up the yams and cranberries. I pray that you have a wonderful day with family, giving thanks to the ON [...]
Pingback by ChoosingHome Blog » (November 24, 2005 @ 12:49 pm )
Sounds yummy, Amy. Baking the turkey upside down is a brilliant plan. I mentioned it to my husband, and he said “How would you flip it back over?” which was a good question, and one I couldn’t answer… Do you carve it upside down?
Comment by Kathy (November 26, 2005 @ 10:48 pm )
I cooked it for an hour and a half upside down, then flipped it very carefully with two large forks and an extra set of hands so it could brown on top. It’s not too difficult if the turkey is 20 lbs. or less.
I’m (almost) always pregnant…what kind of question is that?! Of course, I like (dill) pickles. Sweet pickles, on the other hand, are for people who like cranberry sauce.
Comment by Amy (November 27, 2005 @ 5:20 pm )
When I read this post, I thought I’d have to leave a comment to stand up for the delectation that is canned jellied cranberry sauce eaten in every bite with the turkey or chicken at any time of year, but I see that’s already been done at least ten times over.
So I’ll just say I avidly dislike pickles of any kind, whilst my son and I have to have canned jellied cranberry sauce vividly present in each mouthful of turkey sandwich, January through December.
December blessings on your household and children and husband and baby-developing. Came via Amanda Witt.
Comment by Katherine (December 3, 2005 @ 8:27 am )
I adore cranberry sauce. I make it myself, and I make it so tart that I almost wince when I eat it. I think you either have a sour tooth or you don’t, and I emphatically do.
Comment by Jamie (December 8, 2005 @ 10:07 am )
[...] Twas the week before Thanksgiving and time to talk about how much we all lovvvve that cranberry sauce. After all the fuss ya’ll made last year, I went ahead and served it. It’s not like me to let my convictions crack under pressure, but I do a lot of things in the spirit of hospitality. (Like refrain from licking the spoon when I cook.) It seems a certain generation still has an affinity for cranberry sauce with the lines from the can still on it. Do me a favor, eh? If you’re going to serve the canned cranberry, at least mush it up in a nice little glass bowl or something? [...]
Pingback by Amy’s Humble Musings » Annual Cranberry Post - 2006 (November 15, 2006 @ 11:19 pm )