Captives
Thursday, Apr 20, 2006
Children are just cheap pieces in a society that wants them only as cogs in its dark culture[;] [F]uture consumers [--] the more distraught the family life, the better consumers they are. ~Northern Farmer
After reflecting on that tidbit from Northern Farmer, I finally placed a hold on a copy of Crunchy Cons. Per the internet buzz, Crunchy Cons is the book written by Rod Dreher, a Birkenstock wearing, countercultural conservative. The interview with the author is well worth a read. You’ll agree and you’ll disagree, but you’ll be glad you took the time to read it. (Click over, but don’t forget to come back.)
In the interview, he relates a conversation with a family who critiques the typical Ameri-Christian lifestyle, one in which faith and practice are compartmentalized. I’ve thought as much for years, but if you mention it aloud, the “Jesus-Is-Your-Buddy folks” will pull out the trump card. The ace of spades, of course, is, “Judge not…” Since I live in a glass (chicken) house, however, I’ll duck and allow Rod Dreher to toss a stone:
I interviewed a woman for the book who lived with her family in Midland, Texas. She and her husband were Presbyterians, and they were church planters there, and they had eight kids, and they were home schooling, and they ate a lot of natural food, and no TV, the whole magilla, and you know she told me, “It’s the weirdest thing, we’re living in the most Christian, most Republican place we’ve ever lived, and we look around and we can’t see how people’s faith affects the way they live their lives at all. They’re all captives to the consumer culture. They’re all buying their kids the most expensive new things. She said that’s not how Christians are supposed to live; that’s not how conservatives are supposed to live. They’ve sold out to the values of the world, and think that as long as they profess to hold the beliefs of the Christian faith, that that’s enough. (emphasis mine)
What does rejecting modern consumerism have to do with living Biblically? Just this: it is impossible to live a Biblical life while being “captives to the consumer culture.” It’s that easy– once you consider that Christians are called to be slaves to only one Master. It’s about being thoughtful, aware, and deliberate about our decisions. It’s about thinking through the consequences of our everyday choices. It’s about choosing how to live life, instead of just allowing “them” to tell you how to do it or just doing it because that is what we do. It is about fulfilling your purpose to glorify God and to enjoy Him forever.
If you decide to turn on the TV, at least let it be because it is a thoughtful choice–not just an automatic ritual, the habitual flick of the wrist every evening. If you’re really feeling adventurous, ask and answer the question, Hey, wait a second… why do I have a TV, anyway? (Yes, we have one.)
Of course, the problem isn’t that we disagree that consumerism has run amuck, but that we’re so entrapped that we don’t even realize we’re slaves. In spite of this trend, however, there is a growing movement of Christians who are merging their Sunday faith with the rest of the week. They’re unplugging, literally and figuratively. The blinking lights of many modern gadgets might arguably be neutral in nature, but to the degree in which we are captive to their rule, our own lights will only continue to be overshadowed.
Some people have mistakenly thought that, well, this Crunchy Con stuff, you’re telling people they’re not as good if they don’t eat organic, or if they don’t live in the right kind of house, or wear the right kind of clothes, and I tell them, boy, you have the wrong idea. Like I said, my wife and I shop at Wal-Mart when we need to; this is not an ideology. This is about living out the call to holiness in every possible way. We do the best we can to put God and our family first, and in the book I’ve identified some ways I think of doing that, from a conservative point of view, but these are means, not ends in themselves. ~Rod Dreher
29 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
I loved this entry, and especially this quote: “Just this: it is impossible to live a Biblical life while being ‘captives to the consumer culture.’” Yes! I absolutely agree, and love hearing that I’m not the only one who feels this way.
“For the grace of God that brings salvation has appeared to all men. It teaches us to say “No” to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age, while we wait for the blessed hope- the glorious appearing of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all wickedness and to purify for himself a people that are his very own, eager to do what is good.” (Titus 2:11-14)
Blessings,
Stacy
Comment by reforming mama (April 20, 2006 @ 9:18 pm )
I have been wanting to do a post about just such a thing for a while, but I do not write nearly as eloquently. Thanks for posting this. I will just have to send all of my readers over here to read “my” thoughts!
Comment by Lori (April 20, 2006 @ 10:04 pm )
Thought-provoking.
I can tell by this post that (hopefully!) you are getting more sleep. Thanks for sharing.
Comment by Andrea (April 21, 2006 @ 5:26 am )
Thank you so much for writing this post. I too have wanted to express this thoughts, but lacked the words. I will link to you and hope many others will read this.
Comment by Rachel (April 21, 2006 @ 8:20 am )
Great entry, very interesting. I do pretty well with comsummerism until we get to Christmas. Then I feel like an animal backed into a corner. I hate it and I am usually in a bad mood all through the Christmas season because I can’t figure out how to escape the consummerism and still make the people around me feel happy at a time of year when everybody is supposed to be overflowing with peace and joy. America at Christmas time is so contradictory, everything about it. I can’t even enjoy filling shoeboxes for Franklin Graham’s program for children, because I feel like we are just passing American consummerism and cheap made-in-China-trinkets on to children from other lands who may not be adulterated yet.
Sorry about the rant. Thanks for the post.
Comment by ruth (April 21, 2006 @ 9:28 am )
Thank you so much Amy. My life has been taking a turn more towards what the author was speaking of and I am glad that I have seen it as a young adult. I am looking forward to reading the book Crunchy Cons…..
Blessing in Christ,
Mrs. DMG (Ouida)
Comment by Mrs.DMG (April 21, 2006 @ 11:08 am )
AMEN!! Great post Amy - thanks for being a brave voice. This is an area where I hope that people can come together; you don’t have to be liberal or conservative to think that consumerism run amok is against the principles of Christianity.
Comment by Alice (April 21, 2006 @ 12:41 pm )
You know, I’ve had similar feelings regarding the shoeboxes…and never knew quite how to say it. Your comment Ruth summed it up.
Comment by Lindsey (April 21, 2006 @ 3:00 pm )
I loved this sentence: Of course, the problem isn’t that we disagree that consumerism has run amuck, but that we’re so entrapped that we don’t even realize we’re slaves.
The chains of consumerism get pretty heavy, especially when you add maxed out credit cards and other debt to the pile. Thanks for the thoughts they are something worth pondering.
Comment by Paul (April 21, 2006 @ 7:15 pm )
We’ve begun to evaluate our lives in this sense, and we rid our house of television this year. My husband is on staff at a church, and the rest of the staff definitely thinks we are odd. But in the light of what we have been called to become and do for our King, there was no time for television. Thanks for posting these encouraging thoughts. As we pursue holiness we all will look more counter-culture.
Comment by amelia (April 21, 2006 @ 8:43 pm )
At this moment I am supposed to be in the garage. We are selling everything! Okay, not everything, but alot. And really the predominant thought that keeps crossing my mind is, “I am not going to let this happen again–we are not going to accumulate all of this stuff again.”
That being said, ironically, I’m hoping a lot of people bent on consumerism stop by my garage sale tomorrow :).
Comment by Leslie (April 21, 2006 @ 8:47 pm )
This is an eloquent and thought provoking post.
Comment by Steph (April 21, 2006 @ 8:49 pm )
You pulled an interesting snippet out of a very long discussion (given earlier in your post) about conservative thought and prejudices. I enjoyed your post and I particularly appreciated your find of the Rod Dreher interview. Thanks for the connection! I think I’ve become a fan of the “Crunchy Cons” idea. For those of you who haven’t taken the time, it’s a good, thought-provoking read–though it will take some time!
Comment by Brian (April 21, 2006 @ 10:50 pm )
lived with her family in Midland, Texas. She and her husband were Presbyterians, and they were church planters there, and they had eight kids,
I think I may know who this family may be. . . are they mentioned in the book by name (not named in the article)?
We lived in Midland. . . are Presby. . . it’s a small world. . .
Comment by TulipGirl (April 21, 2006 @ 11:32 pm )
Thanks for this article. I have been realising lately how many things I want, and how I wish I did not want so many things. Our whole society is built on covetousness, and it is hard to break out of it even in my own mind. I have also been feeling cluttered, and wishing some of my stuff could be parted with! It is not that I am a big spender, or I’m always watching TV advertising (I barely watch any TV at all), or even that I have a lot of stuff. It is a heart attitude that I am concerned about, of worrying about money and not being content.
Comment by Sherrin (April 22, 2006 @ 12:31 am )
Everything you said is true. Your entry reminded me of James 2:14-26, how so many Christians (myself included at times) proclaim to have faith with their lips but don’t live the life. Thanks for the reminder!
Comment by Janet (April 22, 2006 @ 1:38 am )
What a great post! Thanks for the reminder.
My family and I are living the American dream in reverse. We had the house, the cars, the job, the life. We sold it all and moved to France to be church planters. It’s pretty counter-cultural. We rent a small attached villa, have one very old brown car, and walk our children to school.
It’s been difficult, but I don’t miss the consumerism.
Comment by relevantgirl (April 22, 2006 @ 3:05 am )
I always enjoy your blog, but this post really stuck a nerve with me. Thanks for writing it.
Comment by Michelle- This One's For the Girls (April 22, 2006 @ 6:43 am )
Hi. I just want to thank you for your brilliant blog! I stumbled into you via Annie’s site. I want to thank you for writing this post in particular. Please note — the following uses terms with which I am not very comfortable. I am not an evangelical Christian in the formalized sense. (I am a female preaching pastor of a small elderly church in a mainline denomination). But I believe the cross of Christ is shrinking in this world because we as Christians are allowing it to do so. It’s not enough to go to the right church and vote for the right people if we are not willing to leave behind the other gods we have made of our possessions and practices in order to follow Jesus. I think many mainline Christians struggle with “evangelical” Christians because they see this dichotomy. They understand that there’s something to living this Jesus-life and envy the Biblical understanding of our “evangelical” friends, but trading the falsity of culturized Christianity for the falsity of differently-culturized Christianity is not at all fulfilling.
This post really convicts me! I will have to get the Crunchy Cons book. Thanks again for calling us all to deeper faithfulness.
Comment by April (April 22, 2006 @ 9:35 am )
TulipGirl, I’ll try to remember to look that up when I get a hold of the book next week.
April, You said,
Right. So long as those who call themselves Evangelicals continue to immerse themselves in popular culture, they will continue to display the values that go along with it (50% divorce rate or whatever it is up to now, worldliness, etc.). I think having a “Biblical understanding”, as you put it, is one thing and having a radically Biblical worldview —wherein all of life is seen, lived, and filtered through the Bible–are two different things. One affects changes in the mind (and perhaps how you spend your Sunday mornings) and the other affects your entire life, behavior, affections, and thinking.
You are right about the trading: I wouldn’t expect people to trade one mess of pottage (that’s the right word?) for another.
Comment by Amy Scott (April 22, 2006 @ 10:20 pm )
I am definitely going to have to read that book! Thanks for a really great, thought provoking post. I often think that the best place to find rampant consumerism in Christian culture is….your local Christian bookstore.
Comment by Amy (April 23, 2006 @ 12:37 am )
Oh, excellent point, Amy, about worldview vs. understanding.
When my husband and I got married, I wrote a table grace that we say every evening meal — “All that we are, all that we have, all is a gift. All is from you, God, all is to you, God, for it’s in Your grace we live.” Living the Biblical life — that’s my desire for me and my congregation — all through God’s grace and to His glory… Thanks again for such wonderful thoughts. ~April
Comment by April (April 23, 2006 @ 4:29 pm )
Great post, Amy! I’m in the middle of reading Crunchy Cons right now, and while it is a thought-provoking book, the reader must be discerning. Mr. Dreher says some important things, but he says some unbiblical things as well, in my opinion. So read it with your Bible at hand.
Verity
Comment by Verity (April 24, 2006 @ 8:07 am )
Amy,
Thank you for this post. I’ve been meaning to read this book and this interview provides more motivation to do so. I added some more thoughts on this subject at CGO.
Verity, might you share some of the specific unbiblical items you’ve discovered in Dreher’s book? That would be helpful and give the readers something to discuss.
Comment by Glenn (April 25, 2006 @ 3:13 am )
[...] Two very interesting posts over at Amy’s Humble Musings — Captives & Good things — have grabbed my attention. I’m still trying to process them, so I don’t know exactly what I’m thinking about them, but they certainly are making me think. And that’s a good thing. I think. (…wow, a bit of redundant recursion… ) [...]
Pingback by Territorial Bloggings » Grist For The Thought Mill (May 3, 2006 @ 12:24 am )
Darn, you beat me to the punch on Crunchy Cons; I started reading it two days ago and was planning on blogging about it!
As a family that is trying to live a neo-agrarian life on our 13 acre “proto-farm,” I was saying, “Amen,” after every sentence. I’m finding that Dreher is voicing every thought I’ve had in the last ten years. We’re not just thinking about it, though, and that drives some Christians nuts because they can’t understand why we’re planting fruit trees, growing vegetables, and putting in a wine grape vineyard so we can get off the treadmill.
Our salad this evening came right out of our raised beds, but we’re the weirdo evangelicals in the eyes of the rest of the Church in this country. I spent five hours on our tractor yesterday, plenty of clarity time before God out under His penetrating blue sky, the meadowlarks hopping through the grass, but I’m the weirdo, environmentalist conservative that thinks it’s bad that all our jobs are going overseas. The silence from evangelical leaders on topics that appeal to crunchy cons is telling.
One day, I hope to think that I’ll be perceived as a vanguard and not a flake.
Comment by DLE (May 18, 2006 @ 8:20 pm )
Dan, I’m interested in reading your review, especially since I clicked over to you on your homeschool series.
Did you say “Amen” after his thoughts on that? (I’m not being persnickity, just teasing. All in good fun.)
Yes, it is weird that Evangelicals would think your back-to-the-land living is weird. I like how Dreher concludes that this farming stuff is a natural outworking to those beliefs that we Evangelicals say that we hold dear. Good for you for not just talking about it! I look forward to your thoughts on the subject.
Comment by Amy Scott (May 20, 2006 @ 11:18 am )
Amy,
I’m saying “Amen” after every sentence in Crunchy Cons. A friend gave it to me because he thought I could have written it myself!
Comment by DLE (May 21, 2006 @ 1:51 pm )
[...] Wow. I have had so much to think about. Between my own musings, Mark Moore's lecture, and Amy Scott's blog posts, I am feeling more than ever the oppressiveness of the sin of materialism. I think what has captured my attention most was Amy's comment: "Of course, the problem isn’t that we disagree that consumerism has run amuck, but that we’re so entrapped that we don’t even realize we’re slaves." [...]
Pingback by Amanda–More or Less » A Practical Step to Say “No” to Materialism (May 22, 2006 @ 4:57 am )