Young men
Tuesday, May 9, 2006
It was a hot spring day, and I had loaded up my newborn and 19-month-old toddler in the double stroller to make our bi-weekly walk to the local produce market. Though more than six years have passed, I’ll never forget the moment. When we reached the store, a kind old woman stopped to compliment my newborn daughter and pinch her toes. My firstborn son lay his body over her in protection and gave her a look that said, “Don’t touch my sister.” Not yet two-years-old, my son had an innate desire to protect his younger sister.
Now he has three younger sisters to safeguard and a baby brother to rough-up. My firstborn is all-boy, yet very kind.
Shannon wrote:
I’ve noticed that your oldest son seems to be pretty chivalrous towards his little sisters. Any tips on how to teach that?
Men crave respect and admiration. If we want our boys to become men, we should treat them as what we want them to become—men. Sometimes my husband will catch me “talking down” to our son, criticizing him, or being generally impatient with him. Greg will pull me aside and tell me to respect and honor him for the man that he is becoming, not the boy that he still is.
When I arrived at church this last Sunday, my son flipped off a swing and ran to the van when he saw me drive up. He carried in his baby brother, who was in his car seat, for me. As we were walking in, I remarked, “Wow. You sure are strong. I’m glad I have you.” By feeding his need for affirmation, a desire to serve and protect (women, specifically) is nourished. That’s the thing about men—if you give them your respect and approval, they’ll go to war for you every time.
My observation is that boys with involved, godly fathers have the best likelihood of becoming godly men. Boys who have a man to throw a ball to, work on an engine with, or to take them fishing have the best defense against our feminized culture. I’m not saying that boys of single mothers are doomed, nor am I minimizing the influence we mothers have on our sons. But many mothering mistakes are forgiven and minimized when a boy has his dad. For me,anyway, this is good.
My son has moments where he’ll tease his sisters, but they are few. On those occasions, my husband will come down hard and swift with a stern reprimand, “She is your sister. You are to defend her, not knock her down.” If he is inclined to backtalk me—again– it is my husband who will bark, “She is my wife. Don’t talk like that to my wife.” Greg is very agreeable and easygoing, and so his infrequent reprimands are enough to shock my son back into his senses.
Ask for his opinion and input. Call on him to squash bugs. Slip him a treat under the table for working hard. The way to a man’s heart is through his stomach, after all. (This works for grown men, too. I know about these things.)
Today my son turns eight-years-old, and I couldn’t be more proud. (Am I allowed just a moment on a humble blog?) He is a fine young man. Last night, my husband and I looked at him as he slept. He was curled up in a blanket, having fallen asleep clutching a brand new Detective Kit that his buddy gave him for his birthday. He is a future man, still wrapped up as a boy. I respect and honor him, especially in public, but all I really want to do is hug his neck and tousle his hair. I am a mother, after all.
54 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Our one (and only, at this point) son is a little over 19 months, and you’ve given me some very good food for thought. thanks.
Comment by Michelle (May 9, 2006 @ 8:19 pm )
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this
Encouraging our sons into manhood is so important. This post is encouraging me to remember to keep that focus in my interactions with my son.
Thanks
Christy
Comment by christy (May 9, 2006 @ 8:25 pm )
thank you so very much for the wisdom and encouragement you provide.
Comment by Susan (May 9, 2006 @ 8:52 pm )
Ammie - this is exactly what I needed to hear today. It really spoke to my heart. I’d love some book suggestions from you on this topic. I have heard that the Women and Children First Collection by Vision Forum is excellent. Have you read them? Since I am the one who is mostly at home, I need some work in this area - so I can lift up my son rather than criticize him.
Comment by sprittibee (May 9, 2006 @ 10:19 pm )
Wow! My husband and I were just talking about how to encourage our 3 yr old son. I needed to hear this as I often criticize him… I so want to stop doing this and this is a good example of what to do instead!! God Bless you for your willingness to share your life and wisdom with us!
Comment by Mrs. Dutch (May 9, 2006 @ 11:45 pm )
Great post!
Mary, mom to 4 boys (and 4 girls)
Comment by owlhaven (May 10, 2006 @ 12:03 am )
Well, being the mother of 4 boys so far and one yet to be determined, I can say your post was most reassuring. Yes, my oldest is about to turn 12. At this point, I still see him as a little boy wrapped up into a bigger boy’s body. Soon we’ll see him change into a man…WOW! God is amazing, isn’t he?
Comment by Nancy (May 10, 2006 @ 12:04 am )
Oh, Amy - This was soooo just what I needed to hear! Levi is 4 and I’ve really been having a hard time letting go of the idea that he’s *my baby*. I can’t tell you how great it is to have some ideas to work with:) And how good it is to have another mom to talk to! Thanks!
Comment by Shannon Miller (May 10, 2006 @ 12:16 am )
SUCH a good lesson/reminder. I had NEVER thought of it like this. Not that I have children yet, however it is a good thought for…brothers…
Comment by Kristy (May 10, 2006 @ 1:25 am )
Oh Ladies,
… but, that’s a boy-thing.
He also, for the many months she was colicky, would come into my room late at night, when I was totally spent, to take a turn rocking, singing and gently loving our grumpy baby….and because he wanted to give me a chance to sleep. IT IS SO WORTH THE EFFORT OF BUILDING YOUR BOYS UP!!! (And Amy, I FULLY concur with the treat under the table thing…it’s MAGICAL! LOL)
DO press in for this. I had an older woman give me such wise counsel almost 14 yrs ago, when I was expecting my son. He has been official bug vanquisher, battle fighter & general protector of young females ever since. He now feels the need/desire to protect us so much that when our latest baby was born, he rearranged his room to put the rocker in his room, so that they could “bond.” This newest female in our clan,at 5 mo, ADORES her big brother. She will grin and kick and “talk” to him more than anyone else…including even me, occasionally. Granted, he sometimes does things like pretend she’s a cannon ball and shoots her in the air
PS Something else my wonderful hubby started is requiring my son to wait until all the women are seated - holding seats and assisting them, before he sits himself at the dinner table. We started that probably 5 yrs ago….it’s such a habit, I don’t even notice it all the time. But my girls sure like it.
Comment by Dawn C (May 10, 2006 @ 7:42 am )
Does this mean that mothers should not discipline their sons in the same manner as their daughters? Should a mother not teach her son because someday he will be a man and therefore have authority over her? If a son is a “man in training” then are we unbiblical in teaching them at all?
Comment by Anonymous (May 10, 2006 @ 7:50 am )
This is so true. My boys are 22, 19 and 16. I remind them almost daily that their job as men is to protect and defend the women in their lives. My last words as they leave for the day are usually, “Remember you are soldiers for the Lord, go forth and conquer and defend.”
Comment by Laurie (May 10, 2006 @ 8:26 am )
Amy- thank you for writing about a subject so close to my heart! My guys are now 3 and 4, and training them to be strong young men who have a passion for God is foremost in my mind. I’m going to link your article on my blog. This is so important!
-Tami
Comment by Tami (May 10, 2006 @ 9:17 am )
i never had sons but in almost 40 years in the pastorate, i can tell you that i have observed what amy is saying to be so true. (i have observed it in marriage too!) so many mothers can’t understand why their sons aren’t more chivalrous, but they won’t give them the opportunities! they want to be in control and be MOTHER! they belittle their sons in subtle ways and don’t understand why their sons don’t want to be around them later on. it all goes back to the age old principle–you reap what you sow. God’s grace is still available to help us change, but we need to realize where the problem starts.
thanks for the wise blog. martha
Comment by martha (May 10, 2006 @ 9:26 am )
Wow, I love it! You are a wise woman!
Comment by mark (May 10, 2006 @ 9:54 am )
Sons and Mothers
After yesterday’s series of somewhat gloomy posts, one to lighten the day. Moments in happy/proud parenting for mom, from Amy’s Humble Musings….
Trackback by BlogWatch (May 10, 2006 @ 9:54 am )
My son is three years older than my daughter. When she was born he would say, “I’m going to protect her from monsters and dragons and misquitos (all really about the same size here in Texas.).
Comment by Leslie (May 10, 2006 @ 10:03 am )
[...] Milo sent me (among others) a link to the coolest post I’ve read in a long time. This author is a REAL lady! You rock, Amy! Here is one excerpt: My son has moments where he’ll tease his sisters, but they are few. On those occasions, my husband will come down hard and swift with a stern reprimand, “She is your sister. You are to defend her, not knock her down.” If he is inclined to backtalk me—again– it is my husband who will bark, “She is my wife. Don’t talk like that to my wife.” Greg is very agreeable and easygoing, and so his infrequent reprimands are enough to shock my son back into his senses. [...]
Pingback by lucentwarrior.com/blog » Whoa, wicked awesome post (May 10, 2006 @ 10:05 am )
I LOVE this! I have three boys and now a baby daughter (almost three weeks old!), so this is very timely encouragement!
Comment by (((((HUGS))))) sandi (May 10, 2006 @ 10:06 am )
Good reminder for this mother of an 8 year old son. We don’t have any other children (yet–still praying and hoping), but my son is definitely the bug squasher when Dad isn’t around.
The other day I was not feeling well and was lying down. My son answered a phone call from my mom and told her I’d have to call her back because I wasn’t well. He wasn’t going to let the phone call disturb me! I told him I could talk on the phone, but just the gesture of him protecting me was so great to witness!
Comment by Tina (May 10, 2006 @ 10:08 am )
Amy, Thanks so much for the reminder. As a mom of 5 boys all under 10 I can sometimes get a bit grumpy and frustrated at their boyishness. LOL I confess I have a tendancy to put down my sons. This is something I will purposfully work on from this day forward. Thanks again for speaking wisdom!
Audrey
Comment by Audrey (May 10, 2006 @ 10:10 am )
Now that another man has posted, I feel safe…
My wife frequents this blog and I have also read to gain some valuable insight… I guess I have now been exposed!!!
Thank you for the wise words all. It is a blessing to see the desire to grow our boys into men that will learn to love, protect, teach, provide and ultimately lead with a Christ-like temperment. We had a series at Church on Women finding focus and the last message was on submission (I hope the internet does not break dowm on the use of that word) and the role a husband has in providing a positive environment for submission to thrive both ways (Submit to one another… Eph 5:21a).
I appreciate how your husband “takes up” for you and teaches your son to respect and love is mom and sisters. That is an area that I will be working hard on as our son builds his relationship with his new sister!!
Thank you for the encouragement!
Comment by Dutch (May 10, 2006 @ 10:15 am )
[...] After yesterday’s series of somewhat gloomy posts, one to lighten the day. Moments in happy/proud parenting for mom, from Amy’s Humble Musings. [...]
Pingback by Pseudo-Polymath » Blog Archive » Morning Linkfest (May 10, 2006 @ 10:16 am )
Thank you for this wonderfully encouraging post! As a mother of 3 small boys ages 1, 3 and 5 with one on the way I really needed to read this today as it is something I have sorely been neglecting. Thank you for sharing on such an important topic! My boys will thank you too in years to come!
Blessings,
Tiany
Comment by Tiany (May 10, 2006 @ 10:23 am )
Greatest post yet. Great advice and your son is lucky to have such a wise mother who appreciates the heart and desires of men to be.
Thanks for sharing.
Comment by The Ohio Guy (May 10, 2006 @ 10:57 am )
Raising Sons
…
Trackback by Less Of Me~ More Of Him (May 10, 2006 @ 11:06 am )
A timely word! I agree and just want to high-light the fact that your husband takes up for you. Your job of encouraging your son would be much more difficult if you didn’t have authority that he respected.
The question anonymous brings up, though, bears some thought: Does this mean that mothers should not discipline their sons in the same manner as their daughters? Should a mother not teach her son because someday he will be a man and therefore have authority over her? If a son is a “man in training” then are we unbiblical in teaching them at all?
To be in authority, one must able to submit to authority. A man learns that first in submitting to his mother’s authority. She is, after all, the parent.
Comment by Rebecca (May 10, 2006 @ 11:39 am )
Amy - I linked to this post on my blog at http://www.idylwild.blogspot.com
Thank you again for the advice! I can’t tell you how much I appreciate it!
Comment by Shannon Miller (May 10, 2006 @ 11:46 am )
Amy, I love this post. Just last week, my husband knocked on the kitchen window, motioning me to come outside. I walked out the back door and then I saw my not-quite-seven-year-old son. He was driving our riding our lawn mower! I had a very strong desire to go and yank him from the jaws of sure disaster but I refrained. My husband has been training him all along, first by letting him sit on his lap and then just gradually giving him more and more control. Noah (our son) not only survived, but did a wonderful job and as you say, he took great pride in his accomplishment. I am thankful for my husband who took the time and has been teaching our son over the years. I’m also thankful for my son who is quickly becoming a man. What a blessing your post was. I read your blog everyday.
Comment by Joanna (May 10, 2006 @ 11:52 am )
You minister to many hearts and minds with your inspiring posts! We should all be spurred along to live in a closer daily walk with our Lord. Making practical applications each and everyday is key. The family unit is the most important evangelical mission out there. If families can be reformed to raise little arrows for the kingdom of Christ, then much would change about our culture. It is baby steps but vital ones. The practical applications you offer encourage this. Train the boys to be men and fathers, Train the girls to be wives and mothers. We have to have a “Vison”, as Doug Philips would say. We have to be future oriented, heart conscious, and focused on God. This isn’t a new concept. It just takes a heart that loves God and is willing to take the short and narrow. God is our strength through it all!! Thanks again!
Comment by Stephanie (May 10, 2006 @ 1:09 pm )
So, so true. Thank-you for reminding me of this. I’m not a mother, but someday, I hope to have a son to raise up into a man with a heart after God.
Comment by Lois (May 10, 2006 @ 1:43 pm )
My son recently turned ten and I am so glad to be married to someone who can help him learn to be a “Man”. I just asked my husband today if he would write for Peter a “Manual to Manhood” so he’ll have a record of the profound things he’s learning. The two of them sit and have long talks about what it means to be a man. They have talked about the current culture of immature grown-ups. A man is someone who has acheived maturity. That means:
*a willingness to work hard,
*honoring your word (”Your word is your bond, son”),
*the strength to admit mistakes with true humility,
*and maintaining rigorous self discipline.
To reinforce the first concept, our son has daily “chores.” And he memorized a wonderful poem written in the 1930s called “The Hard Job” by Edgar Guest, who was known as “The Poet of the People”. “It’s good to do the hard job, for it’s good to play the man. The hard job strengthens courage which the easy never can….” I recommend the poem.
Thank you Amy for your wonderful blog! Mine is
Blessings to all,
Judith
Comment by Judith Costello (May 10, 2006 @ 1:50 pm )
No, I haven’t read them. I don’t have any book recommendations on the subject, per se.
I’d agree with that. When they are preschoolers, discipline must be immediate and concrete. Mothers are usually around to do that. When boys are school age, I’m inclined to usually say, “Wait until your father gets home.” That’s almost always enough to solve the problem immediately.
Forgive me for pulling out the ole’ Lois and Eunice example. (II Tim. 2:5–I have been reminded of your sincere faith, which first lived in your grandmother Lois and in your mother Eunice and, I am persuaded, now lives in you also.) Mothers should always teach their sons, and a faithful son will have the sense to listen. Proverbs tells a man to listen to wisdom, which hopefully, abides in some women as well as men.
The Bible instructs children to obey “your parents,” which would include a boy’s mother as well as his father. In this post, I’m maintaining that while I am home overseeing his schoolwork, my son’s primary influence is and should be that of his father.
A modern, industrial culture– by its very nature– is set up to fragment the family. Fathers leave home daily to work to pay for stuff. While I can’t undo completely and immediately the situation that we find ourselves in, we do what we can to minimize its effects. In other words, we live a simple lifestyle in order that the time my husband is home can be spent on worthwhile projects with his sons instead of being spent polishing, repairing, and maintaining crap. (Yes, I said that word.) We have about ten more years of TIME with our first son, and we try to deliberately consider our activities, purchases, and involvements to see that it is spent wisely.
A new gadget or activity may be benign in itself, but to the degree in which it fragments our family, community, and/or daily worship, it must considered for its effects. This is why the Amish reject many modern technologies—not because of their superstitions, but for the impact it has on their daily lives. It is worth considering.
Comment by Amy Scott (May 10, 2006 @ 2:50 pm )
One more thing….my husband “takes up” for me?
I thought it was “sticks up….”
Comment by Amy Scott (May 10, 2006 @ 2:53 pm )
This will hopefully be good advice in the coming years! The “wait till dad gets home”!
Comment by Anonymous (May 10, 2006 @ 3:06 pm )
I’ve used the “wait until dad gets home” line, but I wonder if it weakens my authority in their eyes—does it appear to the kids I can’t handle their hijinks when I put it on big bad dad’s shoulders?
And is it fair to my husband to have to come home from work, tired, ready to relax, only to have to go deal with the boys? One boy, by himself, is a different force to reckon with than four boys born in four years.
The issue of respecting one’s sons is interesting. I thought a lot about this when we were reading “Love and Respect” by Emerson Eggerichs for our marriage group at church. I wondered if my husband’s desire for respect was present in my four young sons as well. I thought of our lone daughter as well, and her needs.
Comment by mopsy (May 10, 2006 @ 4:21 pm )
Great post! I haven’t given this as much thought as now I know I should have. Also, I think I need to implement the “wait till your Dad comes home” more often. That will be something my husband and I discuss.
Comment by Wendy (May 10, 2006 @ 4:27 pm )
Boys crave dads. I think I can still remember that from when I was a boy. There were times I could always count on my dad, in spite of the fact that he ran a retail store and worked at least 9-5, six days a week.
My goal has been to lead my boys by example. Of course you can’t be an example if you’re never around…
Comment by rev-ed (May 10, 2006 @ 4:29 pm )
OK, I know you have thoughts on raising girls…if you ever need something to write about…there you go and you will have an audience.
Comment by Wendy (May 10, 2006 @ 4:29 pm )
Thank you Amy! I have enjoyed your blog for the past year, but have never taken the time to comment. I needed to hear this today, it was a blessing to me. What an encouragement.
Comment by Kristin (May 10, 2006 @ 4:33 pm )
No offense intended…
Defends may be appropriate… or protect. Whatever word is used, the key is that the Wife and Husband are “One” and after God they are both the highest priority for each other… even before the children. Bottom line, I will “stick up” for my wife!
Great post and discussion!
Comment by Dutch (May 10, 2006 @ 4:47 pm )
None taken at all! I just thought it was funny that two people used the phrase “takes up.” I’d never heard of it before.
Good thoughts, Mopsy. The way it could weaken your authority is if your husband doesn’t “take up” for you (to use a new phrase).
Even if my husband disagrees with my call, he doesn’t mention it in front of the kids.
Yes, I think it could be a lazy way out if used too often. It is something I say to my son maybe once every month or two. “The Look” (followed by a wink) is enough for the small things. I’m referring to older boys, not a brood of preschoolers.
I welcome your thoughts on this.
You are wise not to “dump” on your husband as soon as he walks through the door. Minor things should be dealt with by us mothers as they arise. However, as they age, children should not be challenging their mother on a daily basis. I’d guess there are other things going on if a mom has to threaten her boys with dad’s wrath everyday.
Sorry for miscommunicating; I didn’t mean that this was a daily thing. Just a thought on it being “fair”: The Christian life is not about rights but about responsibilities. You are a good woman to think about your husband when he gets home. It is a good thing, though, to ask for a man’s insight to challenges with boys. Men like to have their opinions sought out, and they have insight into boys that we need.
I know that my son could be “beaten down” if it weren’t for my husband’s admonishment for me to stay off his case. Boys and men alike crave positive reinforcement.
Wrong Example: “You picked up your socks. Well. There’s a first time for everything.”
Right Example: “Thank you for picking up your socks. That helps me out a lot.” (hug and a kiss)
I’m not trying to create a Pavlovian response here, just saying that a little praise goes a long way. (I’m just talking out loud here, Mopsy, not necessarily to you. Blessings to you, though, Mopsy, as you raise a houseful of boys!!)
Comment by Amy Scott (May 10, 2006 @ 5:23 pm )
i printed this out to read and reread. thanks
Comment by janet (May 10, 2006 @ 10:25 pm )
Great post on raising young men
Amy wrote a great post on raising young men… I like her. She's a smart momma.
Trackback by Our Homeschool and Other Such Happenings (May 10, 2006 @ 11:01 pm )
Aaaah, yes, this is so very true. And I needed to be reminded of it this evening. Thank you.
blessings to you and yours~
Comment by beth (May 11, 2006 @ 12:55 am )
Oh Amy, Thank you so much for your great insights!
I tried this last night and boy did it work. No pun intended there.
It was our 9th anniversary and we have a young one sick with Chicken Pox so we weren’t going to make it out anywhere special. We decided instead to order in and eat with the kids. I let our 6 year light the candles - first time, scared to death he’d burn the house down, but he didn’t. He was so careful. The look on his face was priceless when he saw how well he had done.
Thank you so much for encouraging us to be GREAT mothers to little men.
Comment by Julie (May 11, 2006 @ 9:53 am )
Amy, I appreciate this topic. I have two teenaged boys and I am not often encouraging them enough! I have a tendency to put them down to make my point. You are so right regarding how a little goes a long way. I need to speak less and make sure that when I do, it is in a respectful tone and words of positive direction.
Needless to say, I need this same approach with my three daughters. It is easy with the little girls, but my 17 dd gets more negative than positive I’m sure.
Thanks for a timely reminder!!
Comment by Pam in Colorado (May 11, 2006 @ 12:07 pm )
What can be done when your boy is three years younger than his only sister? There’s more competition than protection. Maybe when he is older and bigger…Until then, I can’t really think of what to do to encourage a manly, protective attitude towards the ladies.
BTW, love your blog. I read some of it to my mom and we had a great laugh at your birth story.
R
Comment by Rhonda (May 11, 2006 @ 12:26 pm )
Thank you for this post, in fact thank you for all your posts. I’ve been reading for a while but I think this might be my first comment. As I am expecting my first child it means a lot to have advice from someone so wise as you!
Comment by Rachael (May 11, 2006 @ 3:10 pm )
Well, you obviously struck a chord here!
I’m guilty of what Martha wrote about “wanting to be in control and BE MOTHER.”
That’s me, but thankfully through you and other means, God has been showing me the error of my ways. Now if my mind will be transformed and my behavior changed, my sons will have it better than say the men in my family had it. Thanks!
Comment by Dena (May 12, 2006 @ 3:53 pm )
Amy,
Yeah… I just want to echo the above entry: you obviously struck a chord with this topic. It’s clear there are many of us mamas of small boys that desperately want to raise them right, and are hungry for wisdom!
Thank you for doing your part, and if you have more thoughts on this, write a BOOK! You have at the very least 51 commenters who will purchase it, right?
~Stacy
Comment by reforming mama (May 12, 2006 @ 3:59 pm )
Just brainstorming here–Serve his sister before himself at the dinner table. Hold the door. Just general attitudes of service that should be found among all family members. Don’t wait to practice when he is older, as you know what they say about teaching old dogs new tricks.
Comment by Amy Scott (May 12, 2006 @ 4:22 pm )
People have been asking for books. Two come to mind that my husband and I have found helpful. The first is “King Me” by Steve Ferrar. It emphasizes the importance of the relationship between father and son, and how HUGE the influence of the father is, and how often we women do irreparable harm by dishonoring our husbands and our sons with our interference. (run-on sentence, forgive me) The other is “Wild at Heart” by John Eldredge. It’s got some pscyhology mumbo-jumbo, but he speaks truth, as well. It was eye-opening for me to read how my husband views things and how the way I treat him can build him up, or emasculate him in a second. It also helped me to understand that raising three boys two and under means I have to let them be BOYS, not girls in pants. I’ve got to let them climb and pursue adventure. And I’ve got to help my husband train them to be men, not the other way around. Just two suggestions from someone who is just beginning the journey of growing men!
Comment by Lora Lynn (May 12, 2006 @ 4:45 pm )
What a blessing to read this entry. I am raising a little boy to become a godly man and I greatly needed this reminder. Thank you so much. It touched me deeply.
Comment by Danielle (May 13, 2006 @ 8:31 pm )