Reduction production
Thursday, Aug 17, 2006
There are several things I wish I knew by the age of 20. Thankfully, I managed to catch a good husband, as that is a decision with far reaching consequences. I’m slowly learning other good things, but I’m glad I didn’t mess up a big one.
As for other important stuff—like goal setting, buying a home, and always having a roll of duct tape handy– I’m learning as I go. But like I said, it would have been easier to read about some of these tricks in a manual during my teenage years. Life would’ve been easier, and it’s a shame that all the insight comes to me so late. Reading autobiographies of great people should be mandatory in your early years.
Today I will take a break from the fluff and tell you something useful. I assume that you agree that a simple life is worth pursuing, because readers of this weblog are pretty smart (even though you still read here). The “hows” and “whys” of simple living –that is, a life that is single focused on glorifying God and lives consciously with this in sight— are worth talking about. In fact, various brands of Consumer Christianity (e.g. where Jesus can be your Savior and not your Lord) is a byproduct of the church being silent on these issues. It allows you to live however you want as long as you’ve got OK theology.
My husband and I often stay up late talking about life, living, and God’s providence. One detail I’ve learned along the way is that a penny saved is much more than a penny earned. But what’s even better is to reduce your need for pennies in the first place. While working to produce a supplemental income is wise (especially if the plan is entrepreneurial in nature), one shouldn’t overlook the value of reducing expenses as a wise contribution as well.
Over the years, I’ve sought to enhance the family economy by contributing income. I’ve taught first grade, held piano lessons in my home, dabbled in real estate, and done odd jobs. Looking back, however, my greatest contribution has been saving money by reducing expenses.
Entire books have been written on the subject, but I think it can be boiled down to two key behaviors: staying home and practicing contentment. Leaving the house costs money and discontentment costs you more than just money. These two thoughts could be developed fully, but it is beyond the scope of a blog post.
As an aside, financial independence (or F.I.) is a goal of many people pursuing simplicity. Not so that they can afford more stuff, but so that they can be free from the corporate rat race. When you reduce your reliance upon others for your livelihood, you reduce the complexities in your life—as most people don’t have the same goals as you have. The good life for most people involves generous amounts of money, not more time with their families. (Most people won’t say this aloud, but if you look at our societal structure, it is obvious.) Achieving FI on a modest income, though, isn’t for the unimaginative. It takes some creativity.
FI is when your passive income exceeds your expenses. Common practice is to do all you can to maximize your income, but there is another way. There are only two variables in the equation (income and expenses), yet people often think that the income factor is the only variable. It’s not. Reducing your expenses is also a variable, and if you think of it this inverse way, the gap between the two is a lot smaller.
In my opinion, it is easier to reduce your expenses than it is to generate more capital. (For diehards, the deprivation is a game and brings satisfaction, not a sense of woe. “Look kids! A jump rope made out rolled, tied garbage bags! Woohoo!”) Plus, reducing your need for stuff is more in line with living simply. Generating more income without scrutinizing your outflow often leaves you on a hamster wheel that is difficult to get off.
Perhaps I haven’t mentioned anything new by telling you that staying home more and being content will help you live life more simply. However, maybe it is new to you that reducing your expenses is a profitable goal worth looking at. Whenever you can reduce your dependence on either the government or people with opposing goals, this is a good thing. As for us, we continue to take steps toward that end, but it sure would’ve been better if we’d started walking that direction about 10 years ago, like say, when I was 20.
37 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
« Previous: Naming criteria, take two
Next: Better homes require better choices »
Return Home
Well-put, Amy–and while the phrasing is simple, the practice is hard enough for most of us. So it bears repeating.
Comment by Mrs. P. (August 17, 2006 @ 2:24 pm )
That is all so true. It seems that it takes so much to run a household without thinking of having to generate more income. Makes me tired just thinking about it!
Contentment is an ilusive thing. Just when you think you’ve got it, you start wanting something else.
Blessings!
Comment by Rhonda (August 17, 2006 @ 2:37 pm )
Throughly enjoyed this. Especially after reading the “blurb” about you in the Cumberland catalog.
thanks.
Comment by Andrea (August 17, 2006 @ 3:11 pm )
Oh, Amy… you’re doing great! I’m just learning these things for myself at 40. How we wish we had starting walking this direction TWENTY years ago!!
But, it’s never too late! We are debt free other than our house… which for us was a HUGE accomplishment! We did it in three years time. The house is next.
The simple life is getting simpler and I am getting more contented everyday! Keep up the good work and think how much further down this path you’ll be when you are 40! It’s exciting to see the Lord at work in our hearts!!
In Him,
Angie in AL
Comment by Lady Why (August 17, 2006 @ 3:12 pm )
[...] Apparently Amy Scott has been thinking along these same lines, and she’s written a great post called Reduction Production, in which she argues that staying home and managing the finances to reduce expenses, as well as being content with a simple life, contributes more financially to her family than any of her previous part-time jobs. She equates leaving the house with spending money, and at first I smiled at the hyperbole, but then realized that with gas over $3 a gallon, the only leaving of the house that doesn’t cost money is a walk…and that not to Walmart or Yokes.
[...]
Pingback by A Healer’s Geste » Blog Archive » Producing by Reducing (August 17, 2006 @ 3:23 pm )
Thank you for sharing this. I so struggle in this area and and have been lately.
Comment by stephanie (August 17, 2006 @ 3:25 pm )
Yeah, if I had known this when I first starting working I could have saved up alot more money, especially before having children. I could do better in this area (I have drifted) but when I hear other people talk about their expenditures I am floored sometimes. Americans waste alot of money on frivolity.
Comment by Carrie (August 17, 2006 @ 3:36 pm )
Amy,
I have felt God placing the same things on my heart. It is so hard having children and trying to provide what is needed and not always what is wanted. With gas going up and groceries on the rise it is always hard for us to stay within are budget. (That is when we have had a budget)
I have found that staying home and just being together as a family is the most fun ever! We usually are so busy running place to place that we can hardly fine time to enjoy the simple life.
Thank you for a wonderful blog! Thank you for sharing apart of yourself.
Renee
Comment by Renee (August 17, 2006 @ 3:47 pm )
What a great, encouraging post. I’ve had many of these things on my mind lately as well. I’m fascinated by self sufficiency and dream of being financially independant. The only debt we have is our house and that’s slowly and steadily coming down.
Comment by Amy (August 17, 2006 @ 4:00 pm )
The Lord always seems to place on your heart just what needs to be said. You have such a way with words. Thank you so much for the reminder. I was contemplating a purchase today and your blog helped me to see the wiser decsion. May we all find more satisfaction in staying home and enjoying the “simple life”.
God Bless
Comment by Julie P (August 17, 2006 @ 4:03 pm )
Wow, by the 4th paragraph I was on the edge of my chair to hear what you had to say about useful lessons. Excellent and motivational post. I hope you do a whole series.
Comment by Ginger (August 17, 2006 @ 5:01 pm )
Amy,
Excellent post. Right off of college I was earning a small income compared to my peers. It seemed unfair since we all went through four years of college and earned a degree. Then a friend counselled me that it’s not necessarily about how much you bring in but how much you spend too. He told me to manage my money well and track all my expenditures. After a year or two, I was able to paid off my student loan and still have a good amount in my savings. I was surprised to learn that those who earned more than I did still had debts and constantly complaining that they don’t earn enough.
Now that I’m married with four kids, we still watch our expenditures carefully and thoughtfully. We need to be good stewards of God’s resources. God has been extremely faithful to us, especially living in the San Francisco bay area. We are practicing to be generous to those in need and be frugal in areas that we need to be.
Many of us are too driven by “wants” which makes us think those “wants” are “needs.” Living simply is indeed the good life.
Lois
Comment by Lois (August 17, 2006 @ 5:53 pm )
Oh Amy how I love your blog! God has blessed you with so much wisdom and I thank you for humbly sharing it with us.
I have a question for you (and any other of your dear commenters :-). Do you have any economic suggestions concerning wedding and baby gifts? Maybe it’s just the current season of life, but between church family, friends, and husband’s co-workers…there is always someone having a gift-worthy event. True, our culture is materialistic and big events are a business. But not everyone appreciates a hand knitted or crafty something and besides I don’t knit and I’m not so crafty. So I guess you just budget for such things? I do love to give—don’t get me wrong, I just want to give responsibly and wisely. Maybe i’m over thinking this…
Comment by kat the cheap (August 17, 2006 @ 5:57 pm )
This is such an area of struggle in my life. We are a new and young family (married not quite three years with a newly turned 2 year and newly turned 1 year old), and have just purchased our first home. I so want to have a lovely and inviting home, but it is not in the budget to ‘just do it’. We are slowly creating a more homey atmosphere, but I work hard to draw the lines between blantent frivolty and cozy. Your post was very encouraging to me. Thanks again, Amy!
Comment by Aubrey (August 17, 2006 @ 6:26 pm )
Again- another great and wise post. Thanks for sharing.
Comment by Jules (August 17, 2006 @ 6:42 pm )
Ch..ch…changes
I read two good posts today that touched on topics near and dear to me. I read Amy Scott’s post “Reduction Production” that discussed saving money:
Entire books have been written on the subject, but I think it can be boiled down to two key behavi…
Trackback by A Mixed Bag (August 17, 2006 @ 9:42 pm )
My husband and I are on the same journey and we’ve come a long way! Probably one of the biggest challenges we have is with our family who want to buy presents for the kids. One of our moves towards a simple, less-cluttered life (which therefore takes less money and time to maintain) is to try to reduce the amount of things we have in our house, including toys. But the grandparents and aunts and uncles want to keep buying! I try to get them to buy art supplies, books, things like that, but even then there has got to be a limit! How do others deal with this?
Comment by MicheleinNZ (August 17, 2006 @ 10:15 pm )
If that is your goal, I wouldn’t get the dog!
Comment by Tim (August 18, 2006 @ 5:56 am )
Love your Blog…
Greetings all the way from N. Ireland!
Anyone interested in hearing a wee bit more about me…check out
http://www.mojo-place.blogspot.com/
Comment by Mojo (August 18, 2006 @ 6:27 am )
Thank you for this blog post. It’s so hard to reduce your spending, though! I struggle with wanting material possessions, and contentment with what I have is probably still far away. My husband and I sat down last night and scrutinized our budget and I wanted to cry, because in order to pay off our debts as quickly as possible, we have to cut so much out! It seems overwhelming to simplify, simplify when you have so much to start with. It’s hard to go the opposite direction.
Comment by Ashley (August 18, 2006 @ 10:34 am )
Ha, that’s what people tell me about my kids too! (No, I’m not equating the two…) By the way, Tim, I thought you just read the recipe posts?
Kat, This is one reason my husband bought the embroidary machine for our house. Most people are delighted with a little onesie with their baby’s name on it. Recently, I embroidered pillowcases for a couple for their wedding with their names and wedding date on it. I’m sure you could do this by hand as well.
I believe the spirit of “tightwadness” is blemished when we give cheap sorts of gifts. (Not saying you are; just going on a little soapbox here.) Thrify people should give the best gifts, as we put thought and creativity into the process. Being generous is not at odds with thriftiness. In fact, we should scrimp and save so that we have enough to be generous.
This is a good first step–sitting down and looking at the budget. Most people don’t have one and aren’t even aware of their outflow.
Comment by Amy Scott (August 18, 2006 @ 11:40 am )
Amy:
I thought I would pipe in on the gifts issue. Handmade homecrafted gifts are so inexpensive. We often give hand crafted soaps to folks. I have been known to go out and get a bunch of wildflowers and arrange them nicely and give them as gifts. We also have talked about drying wildflowers and making floral decorations out of those. The weeds…I mean flowers are free and they are elegant if nicely arranged.
You go girl, this post is awesome. You stated what I had hoped to state in my series on self-sufficiency. Except you boiled it down in one post and I am taking who knows how many posts. Thanks for the link too, with out your links, I would have an average of five hits per day.
God bless, you as you seek His face in living simply!!
Comment by KS Milkmaid (August 18, 2006 @ 11:49 am )
You are so right! We only have one car because if we were to get another one I know I would use it and I have such a hard time going somewhere without spending money!
Comment by Shelby (August 18, 2006 @ 12:45 pm )
Thank you for the encouragement. Contentment is something I continually struggle with.
Comment by Amanda Wheeler (August 18, 2006 @ 12:56 pm )
I needed to read what you wrote today. It confirmed my thinkings. You are so blessed to learn what you’ve learned at 30, instead of 40, like me. Knowing the truth is one thing; acting on it gives liberation.
Comment by Lela (August 18, 2006 @ 2:33 pm )
Amy, thanks for writing this. It is a reminder that I really needed right about now. I linked to it on my blog - I hope you don’t mind. I wanted my other stay-at-home mom friends to come read it too.
Comment by Emily (August 18, 2006 @ 3:14 pm )
Hey Amy, Thanks so much for your embroidery suggestion. That’s a wonderful idea! I’ve been praying for years for something creative and classy to give as gifts (in order to help in our “expenditures”), but most of the creative things i try to do (like small oil paintings) end up taking sooo long and are usually sent late :-). But I agree…cheap gifts are the tackiest. Thankfully I married a man who looks for opportunities to sacrifice in order to give more generously to others.
I guess the remedy for everything is always Christ-like sacrifice (duh, i know…), especially as it relates to gift giving. I was so humbled (in love) recently to receive such generous baby gifts from little ole ladies in our church who must live off of nothing. I’m only guessing they sacrificed for weeks in their meals. Well i know this is one of those things where the rubber-of-one’s theology meets the road and gift giving is a wonderful motivator to live in the spirit of thrift. I think Paul states in a different way as he labors so that he can give to others (i know that’s out of context and paraphrased)…but thrifting on one’s self I think could surely apply as a form of work.
BTW, Lois, I enjoyed reading your saving story!
Comment by kat (August 18, 2006 @ 4:40 pm )
I’m so glad you said this!!! I needed to hear “it’s ok to really stay home”. I live among MANY stay-at-home moms. However, it’s hard to say you are at home when you are always out shopping, dropping kids of at Mother’s Day Out and going, going, going….I have really struggled with being a home body. I have a 3.5 yo and a 4mo. and I’m fairly content to stay at home, maybe simply because it gives me a headache to get it all together to go anywhere with two kids…(I don’t know how you do 5). So, I was comforted to know that staying home and being creative with my kids is a worthwhile thing. Many of my friends are very busy entertaining their kids with parks, museums, playgroups, shopping, Mother’s Day Out etc. that I have felt inadequate in this area, but I really see that maybe I’m doing just fine. Thanks for the encouragement.
Comment by Mrs. Dutch (August 18, 2006 @ 5:01 pm )
Thanks for the thoughts since I’m a ways further back on the path than you are!
Comment by Kristy (August 18, 2006 @ 9:36 pm )
SOOOO encouraging. I deal with this daily. If I would just stay home my kids would eat better, I wouldn’t spend money I don’t have, my gas budget would drop, my kids would sleep better, I would not be as stressed out and we might just feel like a family. I grew up away from the home. My mom hated staying at home. We were ALWAYS somewhere else. I never learned to be content with just staying at home.
But I am young and determined to teach my children this blessing.
Thanks for allowing God to teach you this and then sharing it with others.
Because He lives…
Comment by Natalie (August 19, 2006 @ 10:18 am )
Here’s a way to reduce your spending…just fyi. I saw this lady’s website on the news.
http://www.grocerygame.com
I’m going to give it a shot. Four weeks for one dollar can’t hurt, and if you save as much money as this lady, it’s definately worth it!
Good post by the way. This past week I ran and ran and I realized I didn’t like it nearly as much as being content at home. The more I’m away from home the more I crave being there.
Comment by Ashlee (August 19, 2006 @ 11:32 pm )
Hi Amy, try Laine’s Letters. Laine has awesome ideas for living simply and frugally, plus wise and Godly advice on Cristian living. Love your blog. I’m not your only reader from NZ. Jean
Comment by Jean Emerson (August 22, 2006 @ 5:11 am )
There truly is no place like home! You save so much money being there & not running around everywhere in the car.Come to think of it, you save wear & tear on the car too!When you’re at home you actually get to use & enjoy the things you have in it, rather than feeling tempted to covet every new gadget at the mall.Give me my husband, our children, some home-baked cookies, our home library, a great CD & a good DVD -any day.
Claire
Comment by Fathers Grace Ministries (August 22, 2006 @ 7:50 am )
I have to say that I’ve never been tempted by mall shopping, etc. However, for some of us, it isn’t necessarily true that you’ll save money by staying home. My biggest expenditures other than necessities are books which are very easily obtainable from home….of course, I’d just like to think that they’re necessities, too.
Comment by Patti (August 22, 2006 @ 11:24 pm )
I read through several of Laine’s Letters a long time ago. I recall a good one that is something like “50 ways we became debt free.”
Comment by Amy Scott (August 23, 2006 @ 1:57 pm )
[...] Why write something when someone has already written it better ? So I not going to ! [...]
Pingback by Simple Living and some calculations. « tarnya’s tete-a-tete (August 26, 2006 @ 10:33 pm )
[...] I’ve shared before: Over the years, I’ve sought to enhance the family economy by contributing income. I’ve taught [...]
Pingback by Amy’s Humble Musings » A penny saved is more than a penny earned (March 15, 2007 @ 9:20 pm )