What is sin?
Friday, Jan 26, 2007
Little ones and the Bible
Many years back, Greg taught a class on the Westminster Catechism. There was a pre-test during the first class. One of the questions asked, “What is sin?” The test was fill-in-the-blank, essay style and made for some interesting answers. One answer to the sin question we’ll never forget was, “What Satan made up.”
Which reminds me of another story back when my oldest was just three-years-old. We have fire ant piles here in Florida. The burning consequence for stepping in one of these is swift and painful. After one distressing episode, my son asked, “If God is good, then why did He make fire ants?” The problem of evil concerns us whether we’re young or old.
Catechisms don’t make the answers any easier or more palatable to difficult questions, but insofar as they are faithful to Scripture, we can learn proper doctrine and correct thinking on sticky matters.
The children’s catechism version that we use answers the matter of sin like this:
Q. 28. What is Sin?
A. Sin is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of the law of God.
Q. 29. What is meant by want of conformity?
A. Not being or doing what God requires.
Q. 30. What is meant by transgression?
A. Doing what God forbids.
I won’t make the case for catechism memorization, because I think that daily, faithful reading of the Scriptures to young children is more important. But if they’re begging for more, why not add catechism discussion and memorization to your family time? If nothing else, I can answer the children with more than, “I don’t know. Go ask your dad!”
Sometimes.
A reminder to live well, finish well…
The fretting friction of our daily life
Heart-weariness with loving patience borne
The meek endurance of the inward strife
The painful crown of thorn
Prepare the heart for God’s own dwelling place
Adorn with sacred loveliness His shrine
And brighten every inconspicuous grace
For God alone to shine.
Mary E. Atkinson
This diner’s open
Knox doesn’t know where his dog food is, but he can read?
16 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Now that is one creative use of dog food!
Comment by Lady Why (January 26, 2007 @ 5:58 pm )
I think that the Westminster catechism is an excellent teaching tool for our little ones, especially during the ‘grammar’ years. But I agree that it is certainly secondary to scripture.
Comment by Kendra (January 26, 2007 @ 7:05 pm )
I think that catechism is a great tool for little ones, I guess I see it as an automatic answer in their memory that they can take out and ponder and flesh out the deeper meanings and responses too-little by little as they grow.
Poor Knox…can he read??
(liked the picture!)
Comment by Jenny in Ca (January 26, 2007 @ 8:35 pm )
Cute one with the dog food! When my daughter was young, she put a sign on our front door that said, ‘No Spiders Allowed!’ We chuckled, telling her that the sign would probably only be effective for keeping out those spiders who could read. At her young age, she was convinced that most spiders could read, so her sign would, in fact, be effective.
Comment by BH (January 27, 2007 @ 3:10 am )
Our 4yo is learning catechism–including the same questions you quote here. I love it, and wish we’d known about it when our older ones were his age. It not only gives him answers (now and in the future), but it gives me answers, too–quick, ready, easy-to-understand-and-support answers. Hopefully, our older ones will be learning it soon, too. You’re never too old to learn more, and what an apologetics tool!
Comment by Mary Susan (January 27, 2007 @ 5:23 pm )
We love using Training Hearts:Teaching Minds by Starr Meade. We have begun giving it as a baby gift along with a cute blue or pink outfit (a spoonful of sugar with the medicine!) By introducing only one question/answer a week, my children have time to digest the meaning and the scripture behind each of them.
Comment by Laurie (January 27, 2007 @ 6:05 pm )
That’s neat that your 3 yr old asked such a great/profound question! Praise God - he was asking the right q!!!
We love the catechism, though we aren’t very far into with our kids! They have like the first 3 or 4 memorized, but they really enjoy it….which makes it all the better - it’s just worship!
And I LOVE that quote/poem by Mary Atkinson…man, that stirred my heart/soul!!!! Ahhhhhh….thanks for sharing that!!!
Comment by shawnda (January 28, 2007 @ 5:38 pm )
We’ve been going through Big Truths for Little Kids by Susan Hunt. Each chapter begins with catechism like questions. I.E. Who made you? Why did God make you and all things? How can you glorify God? Than there is a story at the end of the questions to bring home some of the truths. It’s been an excellent teaching tool with our 4yr old!
Comment by Tara (January 29, 2007 @ 12:44 am )
Wow, thanks, your post inspired my to (finally) order the protestant catechism that has been on my Amazon “Waiting” List for quite some time.
You dog sure get’s his food with lot’s of love
Comment by Helen (January 29, 2007 @ 4:36 am )
Um, I don’t believe you have to be little to ask the fire ant question. I have pondered that one over myself many times.
I too have included the catechism for school work also. We enjoy it.
I loved your picture of your wedding day! Dh and I will be married for ten years also in March. Time sure goes by fast………….
Comment by Candi (January 29, 2007 @ 10:36 am )
Love your thoughts as always!
What a wonderful wedding photo and picture of the kids on the top of your page. Thanks for sharing!
Comment by Julie (January 29, 2007 @ 8:29 pm )
Thank you for the reminder to teach the Word always!!
His,
Mrs. U
Comment by Mrs. U (January 29, 2007 @ 10:38 pm )
Love that quote!
Kim
Comment by Kim (January 31, 2007 @ 1:24 pm )
Q. 28. What is Sin?
A. Sin is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of the law of God.
Whenever I reflect on that definition of sin, my need for God’s grace overwhelms me. Oh, should our children have a strong understanding of sin, that they may have a strong understanding of the Gospel. . .
Comment by TulipGirl (February 1, 2007 @ 11:42 pm )
[...] we use the Children’s Shorter Catechism. I’m interested in knowing what version you read for devotions . . . and [...]
Pingback by Amy’s Humble Musings » A few thoughts (May 23, 2007 @ 10:42 pm )
Thanks for the link to the kids’ Catechism–I’ve been looking for an easier catechism that wasn’t watered down, to use as in teaching kids at church! This will be great!
Comment by Aaron (September 6, 2007 @ 10:15 am )