Live well on less
Friday, Mar 9, 2007
About ten years ago, I got serious about finances. The most obvious reason I buckled down was because I’ve always had so little of it. Back in the day, there’d be many occasions when I only had ten bucks to my name. Too, I’ve only ever held low wage jobs, so I had to figure out how to make every cent count. It all began with a simple equation. Before buying something, I’d calculate how many hours I’d have to work for it. After I began thinking in these terms, I began making different decisions.
I’ve had a lot of crummy jobs, but there is one that stands out the most. One summer, I worked as a day-camp counselor for a private school in Orlando. There were two adults and sixty kids from 7:30 a.m. – 6:00 p.m. It was hot. I always ended up with outside duty because the other worker outranked me. I made about fifty bucks for the entire day. Man, it stunk.
So, when I’d come across a pair of shoes or some other money-guzzling depreciating asset, I’d think, “Is an entire day of summer camp worth it?” The answer was always and forever, a resounding, “No way.” And so, the seeds of frugality were watered and tended.
It wasn’t long after Greg and I married that our first child was on the way. I was teaching first grade in a public school by then (see, I told you I’ve only worked low wage jobs). I taught up until a week before he was born and then quit. The income reduction—such that it was—wasn’t a hardship because we never saw it. We purposed to live on Greg’s income alone. Even though Greg’s salary as a youth pastor was below poverty level, we lived well below our means. If you want to have enough to give away, save for retirement, and stay out of debt, it’s not good enough to live within your means, you have to live well below it.
Everyone thinks it’s swell to live below your means when you’re rich, but we weren’t then and never have been. As I said, we were well below poverty level according to government figures. There’s no way that we should’ve made ends meet, let alone save money. So how did we do it?
There are several key factors that helped us start a family on a very low income without going into debt. The first is God’s provision. During that time, our shoes never wore out. After a few years and a small increase of income, stuff started breaking. It was almost easier, we mused, being poor because nothing ever broke! We’ve never had any unusual medical expenses or circumstances. I’m not saying that people who experience disaster do not have God’s provision, just that His provision will look different than ours. In the beginning, we were blessed with God’s provision in our housing, a major expense. We were able to rent cheaply a house from Greg’s dad. We don’t take any of this for granted, but we still had to do our part.
The second factor to succeeding on a small income is that Greg and I are both savers. In a marriage, so say the experts, one spouse is a spender and the other is a saver. Admittedly, being on the same page makes things a lot easier; we’ve always been in agreement about finances. If we happen to fight, it’s only because he forgot that I’m right about everything…but seriously, we don’t argue about money. You can do a lot to eliminate and avoid debt, but it won’t get you far unless everyone is on the same page.
and new handles, we’re good to go.
Thinking outside of the box is the third key that got us through tight times, and probably the most difficult to explain. People don’t want to do without, and old habits are hard to break. It requires a new way of looking at your life. I never felt entitled to new things, and really, making the most out of what we had was a great source of entertainment. It still is. The Complete Tightwad Gazette was my inspiration, not for its specific examples but because it taught me how to think about these things. I can’t recommend it enough.
When I went on a radical diet and exercise regimen a few years back, I made the choice to value fitness, energy, and well-being over my addiction to food and laziness. When I’d get a craving, I’d ask myself, “Which do you want more? It’s your choice.” In the same way, a person who is a paycheck away from bankruptcy must decide that they value financial freedom over a double-shot latte. You have to want it. You have to catch the vision. That way, the sacrifices required to move toward the goal become part of the game. I can’t explain it, except to say that I’ve never felt deprived. It feels alright to have a latte whenever I want it, but it feels invigoratingly awesome to take steps toward financial independence. Choose the better thing.
Let me give an example. Now that times aren’t as lean, we could reasonably afford to spend $300 on a crib for Kid #5. But the hand-me-down crib that worked for #1 works just as well for #5. Here’s the thing, though: the side rail doesn’t go down. It never has. I frequent garage sales and listen to playground mommy chatter, but until I can score one for a good price, we’ll just stretch a little more to pick up Baby and keep the crib with the broken rail. (It is not a safety hazard.) The crib is a depreciating asset, and unless it produces income or increases in value, we ought to think carefully before purchasing a new one.
Things aren’t perfect. We live in a fallen world. Sometimes we have to live with the consequences of our bad choices. But here’s the thing—each little step in the right direction is another step away from the wrong one. Do what you can to choose wisely for now, always mindful that our real treasures lie in another place.
40 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Wow. Great article. Thanks so much for the inspiration.
Comment by Rachel (March 9, 2007 @ 11:08 am )
Awesome Amy. Thank you.
Comment by Andrea (March 9, 2007 @ 12:11 pm )
What an awesome post! I totally agree–making good decisions with the future in mind is so critical–what does this cost me “in working hours”–or — what does this cost my husband in his hours away from our family? Is it really worth it? We have not bought any “new” piece of furniture (unless it was a scratch and dent sale) since we were married nearly 10 yrs ago–we had college books strewn about our apartment–and we bought a press-board shelving unit from Office Depot–after hours (precious time that cost money right?) of assembly–I regretted buying that one new, and yet flimsy, bland piece–when we knew the answer was to be patient, open the classifieds or go to a thrift shop, yard sale or antique store (yes antiques can be cheaper!). It is so much fun to create and personalize a quality piece for your family that will last, and to instill the principles of frugality instead of consumerism. Craigslist.com helps a bit too
Blessings,
Cindy
Comment by Cindy (March 9, 2007 @ 12:30 pm )
Learning the art of frugality is one of my passions (also thanks to “The Tightwad Gazette”), partly because we haven’t had the choice to spend carelessly, but now, more than ever, because it just doens’t make sense to be bad stewards of our finances. I think we will be held just as accountable for the way we have spent our money as we will the other things we do.
When I quit my meagerly paying job to stay home, we had two children and lived on an income of less than $20,000 a year!
And, we saved for a down payment during that time. The most important lesson I’ve learned about saving is, you do it first (after tithing, of course). You drive straight to the bank, and put some of your paycheck in the savings account. You will ALWAYS find the money for the other stuff–power bill, etc. But if you wait to save what’s left over, there never will be any.
Also, use less of everything–shampoo, soap, laundry detergent, food–everything. It’s that way-of-life thinking Amy described.
And the all important tip: NEVER own a credit card. Some will disagree with me on that one, but we know from experience the misery and financial nightmare that can result when you have them to “fall back on”. We are digging ourselves out of a pile of debt (long story–read it on my website) and we have vowed never to own a credit card again.
Check out the article “Achieving Financial Freedom” on my website. It’s a practical, how-to-money-saving article I wrote based on our experience.
My passion is to tell families that they CAN live and thrive on one income. We do not have to bow to this American culture’s idol of materialism. Peace and happiness is found in contentment and wise living.
Great topic!!! Let’s live like God’s people and strive to be financially free!
Comment by Kelly (March 9, 2007 @ 12:44 pm )
Great post! We have lived on less than 24,000 a year since our marriage almost five years ago (and baby #3 is coming this April). It is frustrating sometimes not being able to just go out and get what I’d like, but for the most part, learning to be frugal has been a great adventure and often quite enjoyable.
There’s nothing like getting a $130 skirt suit with tags still on for $3. It makes all the times I put off buying something worth it.
Comment by Margaret (March 9, 2007 @ 1:53 pm )
After 6 babies, our crib sides won’t stay UP! I have to stick a Q-tip in the notch hole so the baby won’t bale out. I’m talking hard core frugal!
Comment by Connie (March 9, 2007 @ 3:38 pm )
Amy,
I have been looking for someone to give our crib to. It is yours. Maple Jenny Lind style. We also have a matching changing table. Let me know!
Tracey
Comment by Tracey (March 9, 2007 @ 4:44 pm )
I too, was totally motivated by Tightwad Gazette! It really made me see how wasteful I had been for the first five years of our marriage!
So, are you going to give us some more frugal tips?
BTW, I loved the last posts you did on raising three under three! Thanks!
Comment by Anita (March 9, 2007 @ 4:49 pm )
Tracey! Thank you for that card and gift on my doorstep last night! I found it. That was so sweet of you. And hey, I wasn’t dropping any hints about the crib, but we should talk.
Anita, I have a few more ideas but getting time to type and think comes in spurts. (The thinking part is very rare, obviously.) We’ll see if I have a chance before I forget.
Comment by Amy Scott (March 9, 2007 @ 5:15 pm )
This was great. I happened to find your site by what some woud say was an accident. However, I feel it was the Lord’s divine intervention. I look forward to reading more of your “musings”.
Comment by Nichole (March 9, 2007 @ 5:47 pm )
Great post Amy! As a husband and leader of our family of five, your post was a sobering reminder for better managing our finances.
Comment by Patrick (March 9, 2007 @ 7:34 pm )
I am an estate sale queen. And a thrift store princess. I love getting a deal. Thanks for sharing your perspective on frugality. When I reassessed where our money was going, a few years ago, I found lots of great ways to save. My favorite by far, even though it is little, is baking my own bread. We go through two loafs of awesome whole wheat a week and it smells great baking. Both loaves cost about fifty cents to make, but to buy a great whole grain loaf I was spending $2.79 each. I love to hear other peoples stories. Thanks for sharing!
Kathy
http://www.lessonsfromthelaundry.com
Comment by Kathy (March 9, 2007 @ 8:09 pm )
Yet another inspiring post! We’ve been able to keep me unemployed for the past nineteen years because of our tightwad principles. Amy Dacyczyn’s newsletters were a great help in giving us the information and enthusiasm we needed to stay the course.
Comment by Anonymous (March 9, 2007 @ 8:30 pm )
I cross stitched this poem and kept in on our fridge when my husband was in Bible college…we were in our late 20’s with two children in private Christian school…
“Use it up, wear it out,
Make it do, do without.”
That was my mantra then, and still is….I love seeing how far I can get our money to go….love that more than buying stuff….
I find less stuff is a plus….almost a year ago due to a job transfer we had to put our household belongings into storage…they’re still there and we (my husband and I) are living in 500 sq. feet….we have one very small closet…I honestly don’t miss all the stuff in storage and if we had to do without it the rest of our lives it would be fine…besides, you can always get more stuff…and that is fun….more bargains to hunt.
Frugality can become an addiction…my problem is letting go of money….we have a suplus now, but I still don’t spend much more than I ever did….growing up, money was in short supply so limited finances were the rule in my life…not saying I don’t enjoy the occasional indulgence, albeit rare…like the $3-$4 frappachino from Starbucks and such….but I’m always thinking I can get my blender out and make a copy for pennies on the dollar.
Our move gave me a neighbor from India who is a vegetarian…and I, who love Indian food, have been learning how to cook “Indian”…talk about money saving cuisine! Dal, legumes, lentils….are cheap sources of protein…and cost pennies….You can take a small potato or two, a tomato, some chopped onion, garlic, some spices and prepare a feast…it’s amazing…if you want to save money, explore Indian cooking.
One last thought: don’t be penny wise and pound (as in the English pound) foolish….sometimes it saves money to spend more…for example, if you hire someone to paint your house and use cheap house paint to save a few bucks, you’ll have the total expense again in probably 3-5 years…whereas, spending a little more on paint up front, your paint job will likely last 10-20 years depending on weather conditions (all this assumes you don’t skimp on prepping the house for painting.)
Comment by Cathy (March 9, 2007 @ 10:38 pm )
I love being able to save and live debt free. But my peers do look down on me for not purchasing the Louis Vuitton bag. Even my mum roars with anger when I told her I will never be interested in getting a BMW.
It’s not like I live among very wealthy people. All these purchases were meant to be made on credit. It feels in order go gain respect, you should go deep in to debt and live above your means. Very frustrating to fight this every day.
Comment by Hilary (March 10, 2007 @ 4:13 am )
Amy - I think this is the first time I’ve visited your blog; but it won’t be the last. You’re going on my blogroll for sure!
This post is absolutely excellent! It is definately outlining what I believe the Lord would have us to know.
May His richest blessings be upon you and your family.
Comment by Armen (March 10, 2007 @ 7:03 am )
Very well written! It’s so encouraging to hear that others out there feel the same way we do!
God bless you and your family!
Comment by Christi (March 10, 2007 @ 8:32 am )
What an inspiring post. And the comments from families making in on under 30K a year are so encouraging! Living well beneath your means was not something modeled for me growing up. And, it’s not a habit that I’ve really considered before. It seems like things are always so tight that it’s just impossible. You’ve inspired me to sit down with my husband and really examine how we can change our habits to make that happen.
Thanks, Amy!
Comment by Kendra (March 10, 2007 @ 9:43 am )
Great post! We make it on one income as well…we do it by staying off the “retail grid” so to speak. I shop thrift stores and secondhand almost exclusively. It challenges the imagination, for sure.
God bless.
Comment by Alexandra (March 10, 2007 @ 11:27 am )
This post is excellent and a wonderful gentle reminder of how we should be good stewards of our money. I love the part about your summer job and really thinking about whether something was worth all of the work you did that day. Thank you so much for sharing this!
Comment by Amy (March 10, 2007 @ 11:41 am )
Amy what a blessing it is, when I feel as though I can’t make another dollar streach to read something so uplifting. (sigh) I have been reading your blog for a couple of months. Since a friend recomended it when I begian home schooling. It has been great! I love hearing that there is someone else out there that belives in living life to the fullest not the richest. We strive to teach our girls(all three) that money is not the root of happiness our lord is. Agian thanks. Another greatful Mom!
Comment by Jessica (March 10, 2007 @ 5:18 pm )
You are so right !!! Amy D was my inspiration too - also Beatrix Potter - the Flopsy Bunnies were very improvident and cheerful ! What every happened to Amy D - does she do anything on the frugal front anymore. Her children must be quite grown now - wasnt she going to do a cookbook - does anyone know
Comment by Lizzie (March 10, 2007 @ 6:29 pm )
[...] Amy’s Humble Musings; read the rest here. 11 March 2007 [...]
Pingback by .|. inspirations .|. :: financial wisdom :: March :: 2007 (March 11, 2007 @ 2:00 pm )
Thanks for this site Amy, I do enjoy it! I’m always looking for money saving tips, but mostly I know that my husband and I just spend too much on FOOD. Everything else we do without or get it cheaply. But something about food really draws us, especially restaurant food. I’m not a good cook, so maybe that’s it.

Comment by Amy Roller (March 11, 2007 @ 8:43 pm )
Thanks for a great post–so encouraging right when and WHERE I need it.As a single Mom “broke” is my middle name, but I’m working to change it. Dave Ramsey’s great program, encouraging blogs and books are all helping. I really appreciate your story. Keep writing on frugal living. It’s a less for the whole country. With the ever-growing Adjustable Rate Mortgage crisis in the headlines and other harbringers of depression/recession looming, way more people will need this information than ever imagined they would!
Comment by Lisa (March 12, 2007 @ 8:06 am )
Thanks for this, I needed it today!! Sometimes it is hard to forget when my spending finger gets “itchy”! My personal favorite provision was getting an old but solid and well made bunk bed off of Freecycle. We sanded it down (it is solid wood!) and stained it and it looks fantastic. To get a new bunk bed (not as well constructed) would at the very minimum cost $200.00. The Lord is certainly faithful.
Comment by Angel (March 12, 2007 @ 10:30 am )
Thanks for the post Amy! My husband and I also decided to live only on his salary as a married couple. My salary goes to paying off the little bit of my student loan from college (only a couple payments left!!!) and the rest goes into savings. We have more in savings than either of us imagined we would in such a short period of time and we’re feeling so blessed by God’s provision. We’re not believers of the “prosperity gospel” that is being preached by some “smiling” preachers these days, rather we feel is it just important to be good stewards of what God has given us. There are certainly still times when I’d like to buy something frivolous, but the same cautious thoughts run through my head now (”Is this REALLY worth the money?”, “Am I still going to want to wear this three years from now?”, etc.). God gives His children so much freedom when they don’t burden themselves down with debt and worry over money. After all, how does all that debt glorify God?
Comment by catherine (March 12, 2007 @ 1:48 pm )
That was a great and TIMELY article for me. My husband just went and did the taxes, and I paid some bills and thought, where did the money go? We often get the “latte’s” in life. We are no stranger to low income. When we were first married, we had very little and yet always had enough. The more we get, the less we have. How ironic! Thank you again!
Comment by Lisa (March 12, 2007 @ 3:34 pm )
Planning ahead seems to be the name of the game. Frugality is a life-plan. It can start anytime, but it has made things so much easier on us to have practiced it since the beginning, rather than put our oar in half-way down a swiftly moving current. Our current lifestyle (1 meager FT income; previous to that, 2 PT incomes; previous to that, 1 PT income) is only possible because of the choices we’ve made. Waste not, want not.
I love posts like this. People need to talk about it more often…it inspires the masses!
Comment by a. borealis (March 13, 2007 @ 3:40 pm )
Please link to me on your blog. I do visit you occasionally and you are linked on my blog
http://uriahtweston.blogspot.com
thanks.
Comment by UTW (March 13, 2007 @ 4:57 pm )
Wow! i really needed your post today. i’m off to check that gazette you mentioned. My DH and i are working to pay off our debt and it’s so hard. i guess my DH is the spender but not always sometimes i just go crazy and i then of course i get so mad at my self for it.. so i’ve been wanting to work on my fruality.. LOL
anyways i’m putting you in my bloglines. thanks a bunch.
PTL you got that crib from a friend that’s totally awesome and so amazing how God works!
Comment by allena (March 13, 2007 @ 8:14 pm )
Great post, Amy!
I am learning this lesson right now. My husband made significantly more last year. But I feel like we struggled more because we “blew” the money on things. Now that the income is less, the purse strings are tight. but we are struggling less.
I do have to share a quick story though. With our income tax refund, we paid off a significant amount of debt. I really didn’t want to…lol. Afterall, we needed a new washer/dryer and a new stove. But God blessed us so greatly. One of my husband’s coworkers was remodeling his house and ripped out ALL of his appliances. They are only 8 years old. He gave us the washer/dryer (nice, clean, KitchenAide models. It’s so nice to not have the washer bouncing across the basement…lol) and the stove. That same week, someone offered us a King size bed. It wasn’t a need, but a true and genuine want…and the Lord blessed us. It is just so awesome to know that we did what He wanted and were blessed so greatly. We could have easily blown all that money on new appliances and a King size bed. But we would have missed out on God’s blessings and we would have still had those lingering bills!
Thanks Amy!
Comment by momto5sofar (March 13, 2007 @ 8:56 pm )
Sorry to take so long to get back online here.
I don’t know about The Tightwad Lady. It seems that after they achieved financial independence that they live quiet lives now. I don’t see any news/updates from a Google search.
Cathy, we love Indian food.
Comment by Amy Scott (March 14, 2007 @ 9:54 am )
[...] Mar 17th, 2007 by Owlhaven Last week I read a couple of really thoughtful posts concerning family life and finances. Jeana pointed me to this first one. It is long but worthwhile. The comments are just about as interesting as the post. Someone else pointed me towards this one at Amy’s Humble Musings. [...]
Pingback by Family, Freedom and Finances « Owlhaven (March 19, 2007 @ 3:28 am )
I got to your site through Owlhaven. I just want to say how much I appreciated reading your post. Our family is in the process of re-org. My second child will be born in October, and our plan is for my husband to work full-time and for me to stay at home. My husband has been a stay-at-home-dad with my daughter, and will be a full time teacher come fall, but I am in the construction industry and make over 50% more than what he will make. There are a lot of people who are discouraging us to make this change, but we know it is God’s calling for us. I also know that the more you make, the more you tend to spend, so why not turn that around and spend less, because you make less?
Anyway, sorry to ramble on. I just wanted to thank you for your encouragement, even when it comes from someone I don’t know.
Comment by Katie (March 19, 2007 @ 2:21 pm )
[...] http://humblemusings.com/archives/2007/03/09/live-well-on-less/ [...]
Pingback by Well written « Fumbling Towards Grace (March 26, 2007 @ 8:37 pm )
Oh this is a FABULOUS post. I came here because a friend gave me the link when I posted about this crazy commercial that encourages you to not only spend frivolously when you have a bad day, but to put it all on a credit card!
I blog about frugaltiy, simplicity, and general homemaking @ http://www.homesteadlbogger.com/boltbabe. I will be posting a link to this post on my site and on the Front Porch of Homesteadblogger as this is such a poignant and well thought out post! Thanks!
Comment by Boltbabe (March 27, 2007 @ 12:30 am )
AWESOME site! I’ll definitely be back. I’m a WAHM of 3 munchkins and try to be very frugal. Wouldn’t trade being home with them for the WORLD. Thanks for your insight! : )
Comment by kellybstampin (April 2, 2007 @ 8:56 pm )
I am so glad I stumbled on your site! Thanks for sharing your wisdom.
Comment by yale (April 17, 2007 @ 1:10 pm )
I am not sure what I did. I tried to post a comment already so if it duplicates, I do apologize. I loved your site. Please check out mine. I love to network with other frugal folks. http://www.lessthan800dollarsmonthly.blogspot.com I will make sure to check back again. M
Comment by Marguerite (November 24, 2007 @ 1:21 pm )