Principle and practice
Thursday, May 10, 2007
A long while back, a fad referred to as “The Clown Church” or various forms of it was the object of the internet firing squad—which is a tough place to be no matter who you are. It was good and right that they should have been ridiculed off the playground. Clowns serving communion, painting the faces of worshippers, and officiating the service is so ridiculous that it’s hard to know where to begin.
About fifteen years ago, I was reading about the life of Amy Carmichael, missionary to India. It is difficult to remember the story exactly, but the gist was this. Some of the people she was working with wanted to set up a spot to allow the women and children to do some crafts in order to draw them in. Afterward, they would share the gospel story plainly. She staunchly replied, “The gospel needs no frills.”
One of the working themes of biblical faith is that it is not separate from the rest of life. Faith is not only for the deathbed or Sunday mornings, but for each and every detail of life. Only a fool would say that the Bible does not speak to modern day people and the peculiar challenges that they face; only the ignorant would say that methods and means justify the end. Does the Bible have anything to say about clowns?
There is a church nearby that has/had the clowns. (We’re very progressive down here in Florida.) My husband half-suggested that we visit. (!) What would we do with the children, though, to whom we just read and explained the story of Uzzah—the guy God struck down for balancing the ark when the ox stumbled?
From the local church’s site, the clowns respond to the protests with this, “We have had 15 seconds of fame on ‘Christian’ websites that say we are not honoring God, I have received emails and phone calls… that say I am going to be held accountable (2 Corinthians 5:10) and that I am making a mockery of Jesus…’Bless those who persecute you; bless and do not curse them.’”
It’s not my habit to point out the absurd in the evangelical ghetto. There are other websites that devote themselves to this task, and unfortunately, they never lack for material. But my point is two-fold. First, I need to remember not to succumb to the ole’ judge-not standby when there is no biblical defense for my decision. It’s just tacky and intellectually weak. Many people who claim to suffer for Jesus are really just suffering for their own stupidity. This stings a little more if I apply it to my own laziness in doing what I ought than if I just relegate it to the clowns.
Second, the Bible speaks to all of life. “Clown” isn’t in a topical index. This is why we need to know God. He has made a way to do this by giving us His Word. If you want to know what God thinks about partial-birth abortion procedures, worship, raising children amid a relativistic culture, or clowns serving communion, then it is best to plod your way through the Bible. Study the Bible. Then you will be able to discern between the good and bad concerning today’s hot topic.
18 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Hooray! Amy’s back!
Excellent post!! After talking about it for years, I am finally plodding my way through the Bible, getting serious about knowing God’s Word. A few of us read a book (or a good chunk of a book) every day for a week and then head to my sister’s website to share what we learned. I’m reading, I’m learning, I’m being convicted and challenged, and things are falling into place. How exciting is that?
As always, your blog is a great source of encouragement to me, and one of the few I follow daily.
Comment by Charmin (May 10, 2007 @ 3:50 pm )
“evangelical ghetto”
Very funny Amy!
Comment by Janet (May 10, 2007 @ 4:06 pm )
Great post, Amy. I nodded and said “that’s so right” the whole way through. Not many things frustrate me more than seeing local churches try to dress up the Gospel. 9 Marks ministries asks an excellent question: “Is your church reflecting the culture, or shaping it?” I pray that local churches would ask themselves that, seriously, and seek to shape the culture…for His glory!
Comment by Lisa (May 10, 2007 @ 4:59 pm )
Bravo to you for this post AND to Amy Carmichael for saying “The gospel needs no frills”.
Just today while grocery shopping, I ran into a “friend” who was sooo excited about a new “program” she is starting. She is going to reach out to people to share the love of Christ, but NOT TELL THEM ABOUT CHRIST. What, you say? Yup. It’s too offensive, you know, she tells me.
I am sooooooooo saddened by what Christians are doing to the name of Christ these days. All to make people “feel good”. Hey, wait. That’s what Oprah does. We as CHRISTIANS are to tell the Truth about Jesus Christ.
His,
Mrs. U
Comment by Mrs. U (May 10, 2007 @ 6:00 pm )
Are there ANY churches that are preaching the GOSPEL anymore? Seems to me like they are trying to be like the world, preaching prosperity and a come as you are “stay as you are” gospel. We have had to leave the organized church in our area. Unfortunately.
Comment by Jennifer (May 10, 2007 @ 6:41 pm )
She’s baaacck! Amen to all that, Amy.
Comment by Andrea (May 10, 2007 @ 7:50 pm )
Succinctly put, Amy.
It is grievous that we as Christians have become unable (or unwilling) to employ Biblical discernment in everyday life. Undoubtedly, one of the major reason for this, if not THE reason, is that local churches are not teaching the whole counsel of God as well as how to discern truth from error.
Instead, we just keep jumping on the next popular book/program/personality to come along on the Evangelical bandwagon - never stopping to evaluate it by the light of Scripture.
One recent example of this in our California neck of the woods has been the LOVE & RESPECT book craze. And we’re continuing to find out how NOT to be popular - all it takes is a little Biblically based dissent.
Thanks for your encouragement and exhortation on this vital subject.
Comment by emily (May 10, 2007 @ 10:59 pm )
[...] Workman’s Toolbox * A new Puritan’s website. * Over at Shepherd’s Scrapbook, some links to Hughes Oliphant Old’s The Reading and Preaching of Scripture in the worship of the Christian church * I hope this kind of thing never comes to British shores: Clowns Communion [...]
Pingback by A Commentary Short? « Unashamed Workman (May 11, 2007 @ 3:18 am )
Great post, Amy! I would like to add a hearty amen to this… “First, I need to remember not to succumb to the ole’ judge-not standby when there is no biblical defense for my decision. It’s just tacky and intellectually weak.” I like that!
Comment by Rachel (May 11, 2007 @ 8:23 am )
[...] a post from Amy’s Humble Musings that I really enjoyed. Her blog always makes me think. Click here to read Principle and [...]
Pingback by Nothing Gold » Blog Archive » Get Clickin’ (May 11, 2007 @ 10:41 am )
I agree with many of the comments abouve-Amy is back.We better get out eyes ready for some good reading!!
How strange about the clowns.I first thought maybe the clowns were outside of the church to attract unbelievers,like at a picnic.
then it is best to plod your way through the Bible. Study the Bible. Then you will be able to discern between the good and bad concerning today’s hot topic.-Thanks for ” commandment” of the day!!
Comment by Tammy (May 11, 2007 @ 11:29 am )
completely a side note—clowns have always freaked me out and if I saw one in church, oy vey!
You’re on the right mark here Amy. I get weary of the judge-not argument people toss about when trying to use their emotions to justify their decisions rather than going on Biblical rights/wrongs.
Comment by Lindsey (May 11, 2007 @ 2:53 pm )
Funny… I seem to remember Jesus saying that if HE was lifted up, then HE would draw all men unto Himself. Going by that, I can’t see how we need program after porogram or clowns or whatever the gimmick of the week is.
That’s just me though.
Comment by bev (May 11, 2007 @ 9:58 pm )
I agree totally, Bev, that and the genuine love of the Brethren, will draw the lost.
Claire
Comment by Fathers Grace Ministries (May 13, 2007 @ 8:25 am )
I tried to watch the video of the clown service. It was really, really weird. I finally figured out that the video was from an Episcopal church in NYC, and not the Lutheran church in FL.
The strange thing is that the Episcopal clown service seemed more reverant than my church’s ordinary services. They played a piano rag, but they did not have head-banging, eardrum splitting rock. The last two times my church has served communion, they had a team of singers singing contemporay Christain music while the elements were being passed out. The beat and the volume and the lyrics make it very difficult for the congregation to pray and reflect. There was something about the quietness in the clown service that made it seem almost preferable to what I get nearly every week. Also, at our church, there is a whole lot of clapping. Every time anyone does anything, there is applause. They clap during and after congregational singing, for the choir, for special music, for baptisms. You name it. A lot of clapping goes on. They say, “Give praise to God!” and everybody claps. I can’t judge what is going on in anybody’s heart, but I can tell you I feel mighty disconnected during all this.
I was uncomfortable with the costumes, crossdressing and female actor portraying God in the creation mime when I watched the clown service. I often did not understand what they were doing. I could not understand how it was an outreach when everything was mimed and it seemed that one needed background in the Episcopalian litergy in order to understand what they were miming. And yet, at the same time, there was a quiet solemnity (weird and eerie though it was), and the clown costumes were MUCH more modest than what one often sees on the female members of the “worship team” on the “stage” in the front of my church. They didn’t sing sensual songs about touching and being touched by God and leaning back on Him and feeling His heart beat through His warm chest (songs like that completely shut me down–I cannot sing them, and yet they are sung so often…) I enjoyed the sound of the choir in the clown video.
Do you know what I wish? I wish I could find a church where people loved God above all else, and truly studied His Word, a place where there is respect for elders, love for the traditions passed to us by the saints who went before us, loving discernment of right and wrong. A place where people have attention spans to really delve into God’s revelation of Himself and be amazed by Him. A place of love, where miserable sinners can come and be embraced, accepted and taught to be holy, encouraged to change and grow into the likeness of Christ. A place that sings new music along with the old, but only GOOD new music–a place where music is judged on the basis of what is says and how well the form of the music matches its message, not on how recently it was published.
I wish I could go to a church where reverance is understood and valued and joy doesn’t have to be frenetic and loud. I wish I could go to a church where the Bible is read from the pulpit and explained clearly, and people are challenged to respond to the message and grow. I wish there were a church where people would be excited about learning and living God’s Word, and love each other and encourage each other and NOT rank the spiritual gifts (evangelism=everything and everything else=nothing) and NOT call people who want to live holy lives legalists.
I wish I could go to a church where the pastor has a passion for imparting the Word to his congregation, someone at whose feet I could sit and learn, whom I could trust to bring me the Truth consistently, and who would not be deeply offended if I did occasionally question something he said (Acts 17:11).
Does anybody even know of a church like that?
Comment by ruth (May 14, 2007 @ 12:20 pm )
In comment to ruth’s comment above….Our church is like that!
We were in a church for 7 years, actually helping to plant it, and we just recently left (my husband was the youth pastor there). We now attend another church, and it is amazing how the pastor glorifies Jesus above anything else. His favorite thing to say is that it all goes back to JESUS, the Author and Finisher of our Faith….if it is anything other than JESUS, it is nothing. I tell you, maybe I am caught up in all the newness of it all, but I have NEVER learned so much in such a little amount of time. God is truly in this place!!!
Comment by Kristy (May 15, 2007 @ 2:00 pm )
Amen. That’s all. Just a long, hearty Amen.
Comment by Tamara (May 15, 2007 @ 8:31 pm )
While I agree that it is strange to have clowns, I wonder just what everyone is afraid of? If this method has actually brought people to salvation, that is what is the most important here. If the gospel needs “no frills”, then all Backyard Bible Clubs, Vacation Bible Schools, Cantatas, AWANA, RAs, GAS, etc, need to be cancelled. What the heck, let’s go back to the days of the Puritans. Doesn’t anyone believe that God can use this for HIS good? Is anything impossible for God? I don’t think so.
Comment by Amy E (May 19, 2007 @ 12:25 am )