How to make progress with the Mommy Wars
Tuesday, May 20, 2008
I’ve been around the Mommy Wars long enough to know that it can get ugly. The Mommy Wars, of course, are the way women one-up each other in a way to validate their work that otherwise gets no recognition (not counting the pink carnation on Mother’s Day). Some women work for God, some women work for their own egos, and some women work for no other reason than it has to get done. Sometimes it’s a combination.
I’m sure there are other reasons that I haven’t thought of, but I’m bad at psychotherapy. The truth is, even if we have noble goals, the nitty gritty is messy: it can get competitive among the women. I’m still young, but I’ve never heard a man say, “Dude, you really need to get your kid off the bottle. It will deform his mouth structure.” To clarify, I have never asked anyone to open their mouth so I could see if they had a good mother or a bad mother.
Men are simple, but women are complex. (This is not the part where I say that I wish I were a man.) Once you understand that women are complex, though, you can work with it. The world is a yucky place, and those of us with the same goals—like doing right by our children and doing it for God– should stick together. What if we really threw each other for a loop and said, “You’re doing a good job”? I know we need to flesh some things out, but what if we started out on the same page more often?
I got this idea because I was talking to a woman about marriage stuff recently. She’s awesome: beautiful, smart, and a good mom to her kids. She’s the kind that you don’t think to say nice stuff to because she’s strong and anyone as cool as her has to know it. But she didn’t know it. Not knowing that your work is meaningful—whatever it is—can be a weight around your neck.
Every person reading this knows someone in real life who is doing a good job. Why not say it? I don’t think we suffer from too much encouragement that it can turn into a pride-fest. At the end of the day, we want to lay our head on the pillow and know that the day was not wasted. That’s why it’s important to do all things for Jesus– bottles or cups.
Let’s do this. Next time you see an 18-month-old running around with a bottle, resist the urge to gasp in horror and discuss orthodontics. Try this instead, “You are so patient with your kids. That’s awesome.” It’s a step in the right direction. I have this theory—moms who are not beating themselves up all the time for their deficiencies have more time to research bottles and cups and dentists. (Or concentrate on the stuff of life that really matters.) Look, I don’t want you newbie moms—you know I love ya– kicking yourself when you realize how hyper you were. Just calm down now and save yourself the apologies. We moms need to stick together. We can hear each other better when we’re building up one another.
Take it from me, you’re awesome.
42 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
« Previous: When Mom makes mistakes
Next: The road to our farm, philosophically speaking »
Return Home
I have found that every time I pass judgment on a parent, it comes back to haunt me later on. I used to think it was horrible for a three-year-old to be in diapers (and then my son potty trained at 3 1/2). I used to think it was awful for moms to take kids out in mismatched outfits (and then my fourth child dressed herself and I was too tired to care). I thought it was terrible that people couldn’t control their kids in restaurants (and then I had a child with autism who reacted badly to crowds of people). Now I am quiet. I find beauty in mothers of all description, and I try to be a source of support for young moms who desperately need a word of encouragement. Thank you for sharing this message today.
Comment by Raising Country Kids (May 20, 2008 @ 11:40 am )
Good encouragement, Amy. I know lots of good moms I should encourage today. I definitely find myself worrying way too much about what other moms think of me in how I parent…when the goal needs to be to please Jesus instead. Thanks for the good (and humble, as usual) reminder.
By the way, I only know you from your blog, but I think you’re a great mom. Your love for Jesus and sacrifice for your kids is always so near to your writing. It’s why you’re in my reader. There’s something so attractive about a mom of many who seeks faithfulness in all of life. Thanks for the glimpse.
Comment by Lisa (May 20, 2008 @ 12:01 pm )
Thank you.
Comment by Jenny (May 20, 2008 @ 12:03 pm )
Extending grace can change someone’s life. For someone who tends to be more critical than gracious,the only way I can accomplish this is through prayer. I need to have different eyes to see. Thank you for the reminder.
Comment by Elizabeth Esther (May 20, 2008 @ 12:09 pm )
I was looking through all the Scriptures that had to do with encouragement today. There were a couple that said, “Correct, rebuke, and encourage…” I thought, Man, we sure get the first parts right but we often leave out the encourage parts.
Comment by Amy Scott (May 20, 2008 @ 12:12 pm )
Wise words. I have young mother in my life who hasn’t yet learned a few lessons the hard way. My husband thought her attitude might be upsetting to me. I explained to him that it was upsetting, but only in the sense that I realize how many people I should probably apologize to for my “expert” advice.
Comment by Staci at Writing and Living (May 20, 2008 @ 12:48 pm )
This is a fabulous post. There are so many moms who seem to have it all together, but they need encouragement, too. We forget that we don’t see her at 3 am or when she’s covered in spitup or when she’s scrubbing marker out of the carpet - again. She’s might be losing her cool, too. All of us fail and we know it - it’s much better to lift one another up than knock one another down.
Comment by Shannon Miller (May 20, 2008 @ 1:02 pm )
Boy did I need to read this! Thank you! At my new blog I’m doing “lifegiving” challenges, and this would be a great one! Thanks for the inspiration!
Comment by sarah mae (May 20, 2008 @ 1:27 pm )
I think the best rule is to ONLY offer encouragement, unless the person is a close, close friend and you are truly concerned about something. Why be critical? What’s the point? Unless the children are being abused, do what’s right between you and God — and let others do the same.
Chuck Swindoll’s books on grace have shaped my thinking in this regard. It’s easy to discourage. Very few encourage.
I want to be an encourager.
Comment by Kelly @ Love Well (May 20, 2008 @ 1:40 pm )
Great post, and I’m not even a mom yet. This applies to all of life.
Comment by Kristie (May 20, 2008 @ 2:00 pm )
As a person whose first reaction is often judgement rather than grace, thanks for the reminder.
Comment by Amy(The Sleepy Reader) (May 20, 2008 @ 2:48 pm )
Thanks for opening my eyes, Amy. I needed to read this. My neighbor is always telling me I’m a good mom (although I don’t always feel it), and it’s suddenly hitting me that it’s a great habit, and we’d all do well to adopt it!
Comment by Sharon (May 20, 2008 @ 3:34 pm )
I didn’t even get a carnation!
The simple rule that is transforming me from a people-fixer into a people-lover? Don’t give advice unless I’m asked directly. And even when I’m asked directly I don’t give parenting advice to parents of children older than my own.
Comment by Amy Flanegan (May 20, 2008 @ 3:40 pm )
If we understood that being a loving mom is more important than anything, I mean anything else, we might just enjoy motherhood more. A loving mom can share Jesus with her kids. What diapers she used, if she let Baby have a pacifier, a walker, a bouncer, these things matter not at all.
Let’s just look back at our descriptive passage, the famed Titus 2. The older women are to instruct the younger women to love their husbands and their children. They are not instructed on how to be SuperMommy. So if you feel the need to pass on wisdom, share with the younger mommies just how to love their children.
Comment by Rhonda (May 20, 2008 @ 6:46 pm )
Thank you. I just recently commented elsewhere saying this exact thing. As a mom of a firstborn child with autism and other issues that included being delayed in most areas of development, I have been beat up visciously in the Mommy wars. When you add in transracial adoptive parenting, being a SAHM of 4, homeschooling, being a birth doula, etc… well, sometimes I just feel like a lightning rod.
Why can’t we just lead with grace?
Unfortunately the force of naturally prideful humans desiring affirmation in a job that doesn’t offer much up naturally is pretty powerful, and women will think, say and do anything to fill themselves. Putting others down, aloud or not, is always one way to make yourself feel higher. I am amazed at the silly insignificance of some of the things with which women will seek to distinguish themselves, be it ever so slightly (type of sipper cup, organic cottons, etc, etc… good grief! Reminds me of those Max Lucado stories with the Wemicks.)
My experiences have made me so gracious toward other moms. And, yet… sometimes I catch myself mentally doing the same darn thing to another mom, so powerful is that sinful pull. Yuck!! Grace!
Amy, how wonderful that you’re committed to doing your very best to raise your children in spiritual, mental, emotional and physical health. What a significant work you are doing. How wonderful that you are using your blog to encourage other moms. Thank you.
Comment by Marian (May 20, 2008 @ 7:10 pm )
Thanks for this.
As a new mom at 33, I’m getting a lot of unwanted, non-grace based advice from a lot of my friends who have older children. What we new moms need is a little encouragement too.
Comment by Coralie (May 20, 2008 @ 9:43 pm )
I never critique or “comment” about something regarding moms and their kids unless asked. And then, if asked, I do so with trembling lips! I’ve been hurt and been the giver of some hurtful comments. We never “mean” to be hurtful, but, as sinners, we can do it in our sleep!
There are those who NEVER hear a word of encouragement from anybody. I try to encourage the Christian moms that I see struggling by telling them that they are doing a super job and that they are a great mom. I cite examples of certain positive interactions I’ve had with their kids. And some of these ladies tear up. And it breaks my heart…..why isn’t the body of Christ more encouraging to each other? I would hope that we’d be building each other up, not in a superficial way, but in ways that really matter. Looking for the good in people, forgetting their faults and giving them grace just as we have been given grace by the Lord.
And sometimes the ones who look like they have it all together are the ones hurting the most.
Comment by Marmee (May 20, 2008 @ 10:09 pm )
2 words–Amen, sister! Well, okay, maybe I’ll add some more. My husband told me last week that I was a great mom, and expanded on it just a little, and let me tell you, I was livin’ on that compliment for days! I’m only 34, and only have 2 kids so far, but I have learned (the hard way), not to read too many parenting books/articles, etc. and not to ask for advice from other moms too often, or at least be careful from whom I seek that advice. By that I DON’T mean that I have it all together or that I have nothing to learn. What I DO mean is that I too often end up comparing myself and feeling inadequate or feeling judged (i.e sleeping, potty-training, etc. . So, I try to take any well-meant, but potentially hurtful comments, with a grain of salt, evaluating if there is any truth to it, or any room for improvement on my part. If so, I try to work on that; if not, I try to just let it go. I’m learning to lean on God, my husband, and my experience for wisdom; trying to parent my kids as each one needs it; and trying to listen to what God is trying to teach me through this process of being a wife and mother. I’ve also learned not to offer advice, but when asked, to give it with as much grace and “this is what works for me–it may or may not work for you and don’t feel bad if it doesn’t”–type of attitude. I’ve also realized, thanks to this and some other blogs, that even if I’m not openly disdainful of someone else’s choices, I often feel that way in my heart, and that’s something I need to work on. Thanks for the reminders and encouragement, Amy, and all you other commenters.
Comment by Michelle (May 20, 2008 @ 10:36 pm )
one caveat: i have had a few faithful friends in my life who have wounded me in the very best way. their courage to speak WAS encouragement—just of a different flavor.
Comment by Elizabeth Esther (May 20, 2008 @ 11:39 pm )
Very good words. I wish I hadn’t been so hyper with my firstborn. The excitement and newness and cluelessness compelled me to try so hard.
Comment by Renae (May 21, 2008 @ 3:21 am )
Great post Amy! Thanks for the reminder that a little encouragement to others can go a LONG way!
Comment by Anita (May 21, 2008 @ 7:54 am )
Ok, so this is my second comment, but I just wanted to add something. I really think that the grace we need toward others is one from the heart, a heart transformed by God’s grace and perhaps a better grasp on our own fallen condition. Nothing in God’s Word indicates that surface obedience is what God desires, you know? *Extending grace by holding one’s tongue (”only saying something if I really feel it’s necessary”) reserves the right to judge and assumes the ability to do so correctly!* It’s a nice start, but the problem continues.
First (and I know well that this is a huge one) we can’t presume that we know and understand just because we’re also a mom, or have more or older kids. *A person’s circumstances, challenges, resources, support and other considerations are hugely variable, and are often not apparent!* Sometimes you just have no clue, no matter what you think you see or know! Second, even assuming that another person you see out in public is exactly like you,you have to realize that everyone has bad moments and bad days. Think about how YOU look in your worst moments. Would you like someone to make a judgement upon your whole character and parenting based upon that 2% of the time?
Of course there are some clear matters which can be humanly assessed, but for the rest, we need to do out best to let God be judge and encourage each other toward Him and His desires for them as people and parents.
Again, thank you for the discussion. May at least one new mom be spared the joy-killing, judgement- producing tyranny of believing that good parenting consists of making the one and only “right” choice in every single matter!
Comment by Marian (May 21, 2008 @ 9:20 am )
I think a lot of people feel particularly free to give advice to pastor’s wives about how their children should be better.
This is a grievous thing.
Let’s all try to say at least one positive, eoncouraging thing to a pastor’s wife about her children this week. They live in a fishbowl.
Comment by ruth (May 21, 2008 @ 12:42 pm )
Great post…I don’t know if anything hurts more deeply (especially as a mom) than if you are truly trying your hardest and giving your best only to be looked down on and criticized. Of course, I’m not saying that being “sincerely” wrong doesn’t need correction, but that’s not usually the case. If God didn’t think it was important enough to mention in Scripture, I’d tread carefully before offering said correction.
Comment by Ginny (May 21, 2008 @ 1:39 pm )
LOVE this post. So true. There are a lot of people that I (hanging my head) admit - I try to avoid talking to because there is always, ALWAYS some kind of one-upping going on. And that makes me want to one-up them right back. Not so mature… I know.
No wonder it’s so hard to find adult women friends - we’re as hard on each other as we are on ourselves!!
Thanks for the encouragement - I’m gonna give it a shot!
Comment by Katie (May 21, 2008 @ 3:07 pm )
You’re awesome too, Amy!
Comment by Diane (May 21, 2008 @ 5:25 pm )
This was a really great read, thanks! I just blogged on Mother’s Day about how we need to think before we speak. It’s so easy to think we are being ‘helpful’ when all we are doing is demeaning the other person.
“Not knowing that your work is meaningful—whatever it is—can be a weight around your neck.”
THAT is a statement that speaks for every mom out there I think. Thanks!
Comment by Shay (May 21, 2008 @ 6:11 pm )
Good, good stuff.
Comment by Kendra (Preschoolers and Peace) (May 21, 2008 @ 7:43 pm )
Thanks, Amy. As one who has experienced the usual comments/advice/criticism from everyone from my mother in law to the lady at the fabric store to other Christian women, and even social services, I have had many moments of needing encouragement. By appearance, I know that I am one that looks like I’ve got it all together. Not because I try to make people see that, they just make their quick judgements on me without seeing inside my house 24/7. I wrote a post last week after a well-meaning neighbour voiced concern about my level of supervision while the children are playing outside. It hurt!!! After five children, I would like to think that I’d developed some sort of ability to let these things slide (or rather just turn to Jesus - He knows what it’s like!), but the criticism started out the first day we saw my in-laws after returning home from our honeymoon, and has continued to varying degrees since then. I’ve been quite defensive since then. Defensiveness is not how our Lord would wish us to respond, so that has been my battle. Anyway, it’s good to mull it all over, regardless of where you stand on this issue - are you a criticizer, criticizee, or someone who does not criticize, but who also doesn’t encourage? “Let your speech be always with grace…” Thanks, Amy.
Comment by BJ (May 23, 2008 @ 7:37 am )
VERY well written….Really makes one think.
Comment by christy (May 26, 2008 @ 9:49 pm )
I totally agree. And I would make it even broader, Amy. For those of us in another season besides child-rearing it holds just as true: we need encouragement. Being a wife/mother/grandmother/woman means that you often do not get a pat on the back or a well done. It is nice, very nice, when another woman acknowledges you in a kind way. Not flattery, but well thought out encouragement. We women need to be kind, tender-hearted toward one another. We need to realize that each of us is going about our lives in the way that we think best, according to the Lord and our husband, and our needs. We need to give each other a major break and we need to realize that we all make mistakes and learn. We have absolutely nothing to lose in being kind and speaking well to one another — and we have everything to gain.
Comment by julie (May 28, 2008 @ 2:44 pm )
Thanks so much for this post. It really hits home about moms needing to stick together. I like to think that I don’t engage in the mommy wars, but that temptation is certainly there. And thanks for the salute to moms.
Comment by World's Greatest Mommy (May 31, 2008 @ 1:05 pm )
I needed to read this today, at this very moment. I’d just gotten my feelings hurt over a comment a family memeber made to me, but I know I’ve said things I shouldn’t as well, not meaning any harm. Thank you so much for those thoughts.
Comment by jessica (May 31, 2008 @ 4:10 pm )
Amen, Sister! Well said.
Comment by a&emom (June 1, 2008 @ 10:51 am )
So my 26 month old is still “on the bottle” and now that her baby sister is here is always using a pacifier. what will that do to her teeth?!?
Comment by jasmine (June 1, 2008 @ 11:29 am )
Well said. Thanks.
Comment by fullheartandhands mama (June 1, 2008 @ 2:54 pm )
Amy,
Just found your blog via Rocks in My Dryer. I really appreciate this post! You hit the nail on the head. We are so hard on each other, and ourselves, as moms. And Im learning that even as my boys grow older, it doesnt change. The issues do, but the Mommy Wars continue. What a good reminder to vocalize our support and encouragement for our fellow moms. We’re all in it together.
Comment by Nicole@ApronStringsAflutter (June 1, 2008 @ 11:33 pm )
great post - it’s such important perspective to realize and them remember (and practice!) - it’s so much easier to tear others down, but not at all what any of us needs. Thanks for the great reminder & encouragement!
Comment by jodi (June 2, 2008 @ 10:31 am )
Amen!
Comment by Amber (Bringing Good Home) (June 3, 2008 @ 10:24 pm )
Great post! Makes me want to hug my sister in law. She’s taught me so much about being a mom!
Comment by citystreams (June 3, 2008 @ 10:40 pm )
[...] Here’s some delightful encouragement from Amy over at Amy’s Humble Musings. [...]
Pingback by Pursuing Titus 2 » Blog Archive » Amy Brilliant Musing on “How to Make Progress with the Mommy Wars” (June 18, 2008 @ 7:11 am )
What great food for thought! I’ve noticed that competitive spirit flows in families as well. The encouraging thing is that it mellows with the years. It really is about understanding that most moms want the best for their children. Thanks for your encouragement, Amy!
Comment by Kathy (June 18, 2008 @ 9:29 am )